Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

FanNation ranks the 32 starting QB's

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Originally posted by GiantRutgersFan View Post
    typo my bad.
    oh, had me wondering on that one

    Comment


    • #32
      Originally posted by GiantRutgersFan View Post
      Eli or Smith?

      Nobody is in a particular order except Eli Manning and Alex Smith.

      Peyton Manning
      Tom Brady
      Drew Brees
      Carson Palmer
      Donovan McNabb
      Marc Bulger
      Matt Hasselbeck
      Ben Roethlisberger

      9. Eli Manning


      Jay Cutler
      Brett Favre
      Philip Rivers
      Chad Pennington
      Vince Young
      Matt Leinart
      Michael Vick
      Jason Campbell

      18. Alex Smith
      GRF! You still hating on Alex Smith? Get over it dude.
      The Brian Sabean sig is no more. I disagreed with you on so many levels. And then you went out and built a dynasty. I am lame.

      Comment


      • #33
        Originally posted by Phrost View Post
        Thats good cause you were about to get shot lol.
        Just wait, it'll happen. :D


        Another sig courtesy of BoneKrusher

        Originally posted by JBCX
        Despite looking better against an underachieving Eagles team, I still think the Bears are one of the worst teams in the NFL. I smell a blowout victory by the Lions this week and a division sweep.

        Comment


        • #34
          whose josh mccown starting for...i thought he was WR now, hah...


          RIP, Sean Taylor.

          Comment


          • #35
            I'll give this a shot...

            1. Peyton Manning
            2. Tom Brady
            3. Carson Palmer
            4. Drew Brees
            5. Marc Bulger
            6. Donovan McNabb
            7. Matt Hasselbeck
            8. Philip Rivers
            9. Ben Roethlisberger (assuming he can rebound from last year's woes)
            10. Steve McNair
            11. Eli Manning
            12. Brett Favre
            13. Chad Pennington
            14. Tony Romo
            15. Matt Leinart
            16. Jay Cutler
            17. J.P. Losman
            18. Vince Young
            19. Jake Delhomme
            20. Alex Smith
            21. Trent Green
            22. Jeff Garcia
            23. Michael Vick
            24. Byron Leftwich
            25. Damon Huard
            26. Jon Kitna
            27. Rex Grossman
            28. Jason Campbell
            29. Matt Schaub
            30. Charlie Frye
            31. Josh McCown
            32. Tarvaris Jackson


            Eh... ranking #10 to about #25 is pretty hard.
            The Poster Formerly Known As #1SaintsFan

            Sig by jkpigskin

            Comment


            • #36
              I know Favre is on the downend and plain old end of his career, but how can his still be that low on any? Most people look at career wins for a starter and hes near the top, 2 away. I love Jay Cutler, but no way in hell, as of RIGHT NOW he is better than favre stater wise. Remember experience does help, plus its not like Farve has a lot to work with these last few years. All these list seem more of Potential wise other than actually the good QBs, after 5 of course. You put Favre in SD insted of Rivers, the **** would hit the fan

              Comment


              • #37
                I think Favre is still a fringe top 10 QB, but that's mainly due to the overall poor quality of starting QB's in the league at this point.
                The Poster Formerly Known As #1SaintsFan

                Sig by jkpigskin

                Comment


                • #38
                  Originally posted by RonMexico View Post
                  I saw this

                  http://fannation.com/blogs/post/14552?cnn=yes


                  and it was a terrible list imo. I cant believe that Vick and Romo are so high.


                  Also how can they possibly say that Jon Kitna and Alex Smith are better then Eli Manning. People really underrate Eli Manning. Trent Green also got disrespected pretty bad. he was very good outside last year. Here's my list

                  1. Peyton Manning
                  2. Tom Brady
                  3. Drew Brees
                  4. Carson Palmer
                  5. Donovan McNabb
                  6. Marc Bulger
                  7. Matt Hasselbeck
                  8. Ben Roethlisberger
                  9. Jay Cutler
                  10. Brett Favre
                  11. Eli Manning
                  12. Philip Rivers
                  13. Chad Pennington
                  14. Vince Young
                  15. Matt Leinart
                  16. Michael Vick
                  17. Tony Romo
                  18. Trent Green (assuming he's a Dolphin)
                  19. Steve McNair
                  20. Alex Smith
                  21. Jason Campbell
                  22. Jake Delhomme
                  23. Jeff Garcia
                  24. J.P. Losman
                  25. Byron Leftwich
                  26. Rex Grossman
                  27. Jon Kitna
                  28. Matt Schaub
                  29. Damon Huard
                  30. Charlie Frye
                  31. Tarvaris Jackson
                  32. Josh McCown


                  what do you think?
                  I like your's for having Cutler at 9 :)


                  Originally posted by Scott Wright
                  Terrellezzzzzzzz Pryorzzzzzzzz!
                  Originally posted by njx9
                  do i tell you when to flip the burger?

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Originally posted by Green Bay Scat View Post
                    I know Favre is on the downend and plain old end of his career, but how can his still be that low on any? Most people look at career wins for a starter and hes near the top, 2 away. I love Jay Cutler, but no way in hell, as of RIGHT NOW he is better than favre stater wise. Remember experience does help, plus its not like Farve has a lot to work with these last few years. All these list seem more of Potential wise other than actually the good QBs, after 5 of course. You put Favre in SD insted of Rivers, the **** would hit the fan

                    Eh, I dunno, it's debateable at this point, at least. Cutler, in his 5 games was nothing short of excellent for a rookie(with Big Ben setting the standard at exceptional) and became the first since Marino(I think) to have his first 4 games with 2+ TD passes. Obviously he did have a little more to work with, but it isn't a whole lot more. If this is going into next year, it's possible Cutler will be the better player next year. Favre is declining, Cutler is rising.


                    Originally posted by Scott Wright
                    Terrellezzzzzzzz Pryorzzzzzzzz!
                    Originally posted by njx9
                    do i tell you when to flip the burger?

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Originally posted by RonMexico View Post
                      I saw this

                      http://fannation.com/blogs/post/14552?cnn=yes


                      and it was a terrible list imo. I cant believe that Vick and Romo are so high.


                      Also how can they possibly say that Jon Kitna and Alex Smith are better then Eli Manning. People really underrate Eli Manning. Trent Green also got disrespected pretty bad. he was very good outside last year. Here's my list

                      1. Peyton Manning
                      2. Tom Brady
                      3. Drew Brees
                      4. Carson Palmer
                      5. Donovan McNabb
                      6. Marc Bulger
                      7. Matt Hasselbeck
                      8. Ben Roethlisberger
                      9. Jay Cutler
                      10. Brett Favre
                      11. Eli Manning
                      12. Philip Rivers
                      13. Chad Pennington
                      14. Vince Young
                      15. Matt Leinart
                      16. Michael Vick
                      17. Tony Romo
                      18. Trent Green (assuming he's a Dolphin)
                      19. Steve McNair
                      20. Alex Smith
                      21. Jason Campbell
                      22. Jake Delhomme
                      23. Jeff Garcia
                      24. J.P. Losman
                      25. Byron Leftwich
                      26. Rex Grossman
                      27. Jon Kitna
                      28. Matt Schaub
                      29. Damon Huard
                      30. Charlie Frye
                      31. Tarvaris Jackson
                      32. Josh McCown


                      what do you think?

                      umm phillip rivers > eli.... carson palmer > drew brees and cutler is not top 10...

                      i like this list better
                      Originally posted by TPFKA#1SaintsFan View Post
                      I'll give this a shot...

                      1. Peyton Manning
                      2. Tom Brady
                      3. Carson Palmer
                      4. Drew Brees
                      5. Marc Bulger
                      6. Donovan McNabb
                      7. Matt Hasselbeck
                      8. Philip Rivers
                      9. Ben Roethlisberger (assuming he can rebound from last year's woes)
                      10. Steve McNair
                      11. Eli Manning
                      12. Brett Favre
                      13. Chad Pennington
                      14. Tony Romo
                      15. Matt Leinart
                      16. Jay Cutler
                      17. J.P. Losman
                      18. Vince Young
                      19. Jake Delhomme
                      20. Alex Smith
                      21. Trent Green
                      22. Jeff Garcia
                      23. Michael Vick
                      24. Byron Leftwich
                      25. Damon Huard
                      26. Jon Kitna
                      27. Rex Grossman
                      28. Jason Campbell
                      29. Matt Schaub
                      30. Charlie Frye
                      31. Josh McCown
                      32. Tarvaris Jackson


                      Eh... ranking #10 to about #25 is pretty hard.


                      Comment


                      • #41
                        this is ridiculous. the top five is pretty easy. and i really don't like ben as #10. pennington gets flack, but he's the bionic man. and any homer that says VY is better than Vick is just that. Vick has his game down to a science. Anything that VY does well I think isn't due to his poise as much as jeff fisher's awesomeness. He's good. But he's no Vick yet. (and i don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing)

                        1. Peyton Manning
                        2. Tom Brady
                        3. Carson Palmer
                        4. Drew Brees
                        5. Marc Bulger
                        6. Matt Hasselbeck
                        7. Donovan McNabb
                        8. Philip Rivers
                        9. Brett Favre
                        10. Ben Roethlisberger
                        11. Chad Pennington
                        12. Steve McNair
                        13. Jake Delhomme
                        14. Matt Leinart
                        15. Jay Cutler
                        16. Eli Manning
                        17. Alex Smith
                        18. Michael Vick
                        19. Rex Grossman
                        20. J.P. Losman
                        21. Trent Green
                        22. Jeff Garcia
                        23. Tony Romo
                        24. Byron Leftwich
                        25. Damon Huard
                        26. Vince Young
                        27. Jason Campbell
                        28. Jon Kitna
                        29. Matt Schaub
                        30. Josh McCown
                        31. Charlie Frye
                        32. Tarvaris Jackson
                        http://i38.tinypic.com/2aj2s7t.jpg
                        For a good time call (303) 499-7111.whitspacsig by steel man

                        United: "I actually went to the college I root for"

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Originally posted by RonMexico View Post
                          I saw this

                          http://fannation.com/blogs/post/14552?cnn=yes


                          and it was a terrible list imo. I cant believe that Vick and Romo are so high.


                          Also how can they possibly say that Jon Kitna and Alex Smith are better then Eli Manning. People really underrate Eli Manning. Trent Green also got disrespected pretty bad. he was very good outside last year. Here's my list

                          1. Peyton Manning
                          2. Tom Brady
                          3. Drew Brees
                          4. Carson Palmer
                          5. Donovan McNabb
                          6. Marc Bulger
                          7. Matt Hasselbeck
                          8. Ben Roethlisberger
                          9. Jay Cutler
                          10. Brett Favre
                          11. Eli Manning
                          12. Philip Rivers
                          13. Chad Pennington
                          14. Vince Young
                          15. Matt Leinart
                          16. Michael Vick
                          17. Tony Romo
                          18. Trent Green (assuming he's a Dolphin)
                          19. Steve McNair
                          20. Alex Smith
                          21. Jason Campbell
                          22. Jake Delhomme
                          23. Jeff Garcia
                          24. J.P. Losman
                          25. Byron Leftwich
                          26. Rex Grossman
                          27. Jon Kitna
                          28. Matt Schaub
                          29. Damon Huard
                          30. Charlie Frye
                          31. Tarvaris Jackson
                          32. Josh McCown


                          what do you think?

                          Josh McCown is better than Tarvaris, Kitna, and Schaub.

                          And Alex Smith, Jason Campbell, and J.P. Losman are all better than McNair.
                          HALL OF FAMER!
                          PUT ART MODELL IN THE HALL OF FAME!
                          JUSTIN BLACKMON IS A GOLDEN GOD!

                          Xbox Live - Kevown8999

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            LOL, you're too hard on McNair, man!
                            The Poster Formerly Known As #1SaintsFan

                            Sig by jkpigskin

                            Comment


                            • #44
                              LOL @ Eli ahead of Vince and McNair

                              Comment


                              • #45
                                Originally posted by Ewing View Post
                                LOL @ Eli ahead of Vince and McNair
                                LOL @ homerism. At this point, Eli is better than VY.
                                The Poster Formerly Known As #1SaintsFan

                                Sig by jkpigskin

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information