Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

San Francisco 49ers Discussion

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • if we draft marcell dareus, i think he could play nt for us, since we will have a 1-gap scheme.
    my quick smells like french toast

    Comment


    • Originally posted by dan77733 View Post
      I'm not obsessed with all free agents. Only ones I think would be an upgrade over who we currently have. The only player that I want every year who's an UFA is T.O. but since he's my favorite player and an ex-49er, can you really blame me?



      UGH. How about Jimmy Smith or Aaron Williams? Do you like either of them or do I still have to choose better prospects?
      You could just change your user name to Sloppyseconds49er.

      Comment


      • Originally posted by nikkayeah View Post
        if we draft marcell dareus, i think he could play nt for us, since we will have a 1-gap scheme.
        Dareus could do it if we kept Sopo at end. It seems you need at least one end to really anchor if you go with a more penetrating type nose. With Fangio's willingness to bring the double barrel blitz, Dareus, Willis and Spikes and Smith could be a nightmare to deal with if even one OLB brought something to the table on a regular basis.

        I'm not sure what Franklin really weighs in at lately, but Dareus is probably pretty close and just needs a couple years to get the same strength Franklin brings.

        Comment


        • Depending on how the board shakes out (assuming Miller, Gabbert and Peterson are gone), if they don't love any of the players still on the board, any chance they go BPA and take AJ Green/Julio Jones?

          Comment


          • Originally posted by hawkeye123 View Post
            Anyone else think NT is a pretty high need?
            Absolutely.

            Corner
            Quarterback
            Pass Rusher
            Nose Tackle

            Phil Taylor, Jerrell Powe, Sione Fua - we need to find one in this draft in my opinion.
            Originally posted by Babylon
            It's called Karma for all the years with Montana and Young.

            Comment


            • Originally posted by TACKLE View Post
              Depending on how the board shakes out (assuming Miller, Gabbert and Peterson are gone), if they don't love any of the players still on the board, any chance they go BPA and take AJ Green/Julio Jones?
              Tackle -

              Amukamara would almost certainly come before Green/Jones and I would also put Robert Quinn ahead of those two


              If he's gone as well, I think before we take AJ Green, it'd be best to find a trade partner who wants him.
              Originally posted by Babylon
              It's called Karma for all the years with Montana and Young.

              Comment


              • Originally posted by king2am View Post
                Absolutely.

                Corner
                Quarterback
                Pass Rusher
                Nose Tackle

                Phil Taylor, Jerrell Powe, Sione Fua - we need to find one in this draft in my opinion.
                Why would you rank CB a bigger need then QB or OLB? Not only are they more premium positions, but at least Clements and Spencer are somewhat serviceable. We obviously need to upgrade but those two are way better at their job then Carr, Brooks or Haralson. There's a decent chance we take a CB in the 1st, but its not the biggest need.

                Comment


                • Originally posted by king2am View Post
                  Tackle -

                  Amukamara would almost certainly come before Green/Jones and I would also put Robert Quinn ahead of those two


                  If he's gone as well, I think before we take AJ Green, it'd be best to find a trade partner who wants him.
                  Definitely agree with this. Don't want another top 10 pick on a WR.

                  Comment


                  • QB is 100% the number one need. The only QB on the roster is Carr. Which means we have no quarterback!!! and QB is the number one position in the NFL!

                    Comment


                    • Would you guys rather take Locker or Some QB this Year or do bad this Season and get this http://i56.tinypic.com/1pvwnt.png ? A Guy I know at another Draft Site made this. I would rather wait for that.

                      Comment


                      • Instead of quoting several posts above, I'll just comment on a few things.

                        - DT Sione Fua is the guy I couldnt remember. Hoping to get him in the 4th round along with the FB Marecic in the same round.

                        - While QB is a huge need, depending on who we lose to UFA and if we sign anyone to replace those we lose, going defense in the draft becomes more important because it doesnt matter who your QB is if your defense is giving up 30+ points a game. With that said, there's no UFA QB worth signing. Draft wise, I wouldnt draft any QB at 7 because I dont think any QB is worth the 7th overall draft pick especially if Peterson/Prince/Miller are still on the board. I think that we'll acquire a possible franchise QB via trade or in the 2nd or 3rd round of the draft. I personally would trade a 3rd for Packers Matt Flynn. I have no interest in Kolb whatsoever and no way in hell would I trade away anything higher than a 3rd rounder for any other team's backup QB via trade. A 3rd for Flynn is even high but if we draft a QB in round 2 or 3, I would rather trade for Flynn who I think can be good. He just needs the chance. I dont want Kolb who already has a history of concussions and quite honestly, I dont think he's played any better than Flynn. Seriously, Kolb couldnt even outplay a rusty ex-convict. Also, if I remember correctly, the last time we traded with the Eagles for a player, it was Owens for Brandon Whiting. I stay far far away from the Eagles if im Baalke/Harbaugh. Rather have Orton over Kolb but he's due $7.379m in 2011 ($2.879m is guaranteed) plus a $1.5m roster bonus and he'll be an UFA in 2012. $8.8m+ overall is way too much for Orton and since he's getting that much for one season, he'll probably want an average of $8m per season in any contract extension. Add in the draft pick and thats way too much.

                        Granted, Flynn has only started one game in his NFL career but let's be realistic. He has the same chance at becoming good as Kolb does. Only difference is that he'll be cheaper money and draft pick wise. Not only that, but I think we could get Flynn and give him a five year extension worth $25m total including guaranteed money. That is cheap for a potential franchise QB. I think Kolb would want more and I definitely think Orton would want more. And I would trade our 5th rounder to TB for Josh Johnson and then extend him to a 5 year $15m deal which when you think about it would be an average of $3m per season. If Carr is worth over $2m as a backup for 2011, Johnson is easily worth that and like Flynn, would be cheap. Guaranteed money over the first two seasons with huge base salaries backloaded. That way, if either or both flop, we can release them without any salary cap hit and before their huge base salaries kick in.

                        Sure, we would be paying out guaranteed money but thats going to happen regardless of who the QB is if we trade for one so it all evens out in the end.

                        - Draft wise, our needs would be QB (if we dont acquire one via trade in FA), CB, OLB (pass rusher), NT (if Franklin leaves or stays) and FS (if Goldson leaves). I have Peterson/Prince/Miller as my top three defensive players for number 7. Offensively, just WR A.J. Green and Locker but I wouldnt draft Locker unless all four are gone and im still looking for a potential franchise QB.

                        Dream scenario would be CB Patrick Peterson at 7 followed by Prince. Backup plan would be to try to trade down twice into the late teens for one of the other three CB's and then trade back into the first for Pouncey or Locker if he falls into the 20's.

                        - Regarding A.J. Green, if Peterson/Prince/Miller are gone by 7, I would first try to trade down but for hopefully a good deal (come on WSH, you love trading away draft picks, lol) that easily favors us. If I couldnt get the trade package that im looking for, I say screw it and draft Green because to get a prospect of his caliber at 7 to match up with Crabtree, Davis and others would be awesome and passing on him just because we drafted Crabtree two years ago would be stupid in my opinion considering the top three players on my board are already gone.

                        And NO, I do not want Quinn. Guy hasnt played in a year, is rusty as hell and not worth the 7th overall draft pick. Quinn seems like the next Gholston but without the impressive Combine showing. Would draft Dareus or Bowers before I even look at Quinn. UGH.

                        - Sloppyseconds49er huh???

                        Everyone bashes me for wanting to sign a few free agents but its not like im looking to sign crappers. All the players I would sign would be players who have proven their worth already, play a position that we need and would be an upgrade over who we currently have.

                        For 2011, I only have three free agents from other teams that im hoping for. RB Darren Sproles who would give us that speed back that we could definitely use and be a solid backup to Gore and provide a spark on returns plus his value is low compared to what it was two seasons ago. Wouldnt even cost that much. CB Richard Marshall is the second UFA. He's only 25, in his prime and yet has played and started enough games to where he's a veteran. Would be an upgrade over Spencer/Clements and even if we were to sign him to a 5 year/$35m deal, it would be far cheaper than what Clements is scheduled to earn the next few seasons. According to Rotoworld.com, Clements has a 2011 base salary of $7.25m and could earn another $7.95m in likely to be earned incentives. Is due $19.77m in 2012 and 2013. 2014 is a voidable year in which he would make $15.48m. Even if you just add his base salaries for the next three seasons, he'll make $27.02m. Add in the other $7.95m and it all evens out. Even if you dont include the $7.95m, Marshall would only cost $8m more for an extra two seasons and even when his contract expires, he'll still be younger than what Clements is now. Hopefully add Patrick Peterson and we have two new starting CB's with Spencer as the nickelback, Brown as the dimeback and Adams/Brock as backup depth/special teams.

                        Third free agent is K Mason Crosby. Will be an UFA if the new CBA allows players to be UFA's after four seasons. I originally wanted to keep Reed but if Crosby hits the market, I go after him instead. Nedney is good but he's old, will be an UFA in 2012 and just time to move on. To finally have a good young franchise kicker sure as hell isnt a bad thing.

                        The rest would be re-signing our own players and yeah, its a lot of them. Baas, Wragge, Sims, Franklin, McDonald, Lawson, Spikes and Goldson. Of course, I see at least half being allowed to leave as UFA's.

                        So basically, my off-season would consist of three UFA signings from other teams, two QB trades and re-signing our own players. And while it looks like a lot of money, Wragge, Sims, Franklin and Spikes would be one year deals with the rest based on how much they're asking for. If its not in the range that I would be willing to pay, bye bye.

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by dannyz View Post
                          Would you guys rather take Locker or Some QB this Year or do bad this Season and get this http://i56.tinypic.com/1pvwnt.png ? A Guy I know at another Draft Site made this. I would rather wait for that.
                          Just one problem. Since Luck is only going to be a Junior in 2011, he can stay in college in 2012 as a senior.

                          Nice thought but its one I had two months ago and would be good if Luck was going back as a senior in 2011 but thats not the case so its all mute.

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by dan77733 View Post

                            - While QB is a huge need, depending on who we lose to UFA and if we sign anyone to replace those we lose, going defense in the draft becomes more important because it doesnt matter who your QB is if your defense is giving up 30+ points a game. With that said, there's no UFA QB worth signing. Draft wise, I wouldnt draft any QB at 7 because I dont think any QB is worth the 7th overall draft pick especially if Peterson/Prince/Miller are still on the board. I think that we'll acquire a possible franchise QB via trade or in the 2nd or 3rd round of the draft. I personally would trade a 3rd for Packers Matt Flynn. I have no interest in Kolb whatsoever and no way in hell would I trade away anything higher than a 3rd rounder for any other team's backup QB via trade. A 3rd for Flynn is even high but if we draft a QB in round 2 or 3, I would rather trade for Flynn who I think can be good. He just needs the chance. I dont want Kolb who already has a history of concussions and quite honestly, I dont think he's played any better than Flynn. Seriously, Kolb couldnt even outplay a rusty ex-convict. Also, if I remember correctly, the last time we traded with the Eagles for a player, it was Owens for Brandon Whiting. I stay far far away from the Eagles if im Baalke/Harbaugh. Rather have Orton over Kolb but he's due $7.379m in 2011 ($2.879m is guaranteed) plus a $1.5m roster bonus and he'll be an UFA in 2012. $8.8m+ overall is way too much for Orton and since he's getting that much for one season, he'll probably want an average of $8m per season in any contract extension. Add in the draft pick and thats way too much.
                            That rusty ex-convict probably outplayed 90% of the league. What Vick did this year was amazing.

                            Though I agree that Kolb sucks a fat one.

                            RIP ST

                            Comment


                            • There's almost no chance Luck doesn't come out next year.

                              He came back this year to finish up his degree.

                              Also, he will be the #1 pick in the 2012 draft, unless he has a meltdown of a season like Locker....But I find that very unlikely as Luck is loads better then Locker.
                              Last edited by hawkeye123; 03-08-2011, 12:41 AM.

                              Comment


                              • CB isnt the teams biggest need however if peterson falls to 7 we'd have to take him. He is the best player in the draft. If he isnt there then we should definately look at OLB..Miller and Quinn will more then likely both be there personally i like Quinn more they both are great athletes but i think Quinn is a much better pass rusher which is what we need. Personally i think we should stay away from QB in the first 2 rounds...Locker looked like **** at the combine the only QB id take a shot at in the 2nd if he was there was Mallett and thats cuz he has a canon for an arm who cares if he does a lil blow he and there lol ponder i think is a puss and locker just sucks i actually like devlin at the combine maybe grab him in the 3rd

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information