Biggest disappointment from 2004 NFL Draft?
 

Who would you say?

Gallery no doubt

Reggie is actually showing signs that he can be a starter in this league. So I'd have to say Gallery.

Easily Gallery.

eli hasnt been that bad, and people should really overblowing the giants collapse onto his shoulders... he is having a pretty solid year and he had a solid year last year......

gallery has been a disapointment but some of it is on the coaching staff... hes been moved around alot and he hasnt had stability]

williams: a big disapointment and i didnt understand the pick when they did it... he lacks speed

perry: was a questionable pick not because of perry's skill but because they had rudi... perry can be a starter in this league, and he is a good reciever too

my vote went to williams

Correct.

Gallery would be my choice, but I hope Eli can prove me wrong these next two weeks (see my location).

Chris Who?

First things first, I don't think you can put Chris Perry up there because of Rudi Johnson's play. He showed that he deserved that spot when they drafted him and Perry has been hurt for some periods of time.(Currently on IR).


Eli isn't up there either because the Giants somewhat crappy season so far isn't really a lot of his fault. Team Chemistry on the defensive side and a litte on offense(Plax, Shockey).

Reggie Williams has had a decent season so far

So the obvious choice is Robert Gallery. Hasn't played well on either side of the line(just ask Shawne Merriman), and hopefully might be able to show up with whoever the new coach for 2007 is.

Easy choice. Gallery. The safest pick in the draft turn out to be the biggest bust so far.

Eli starts and is above average.
R. Williams is getting better.
Chris Perry was just a stupid pick at a position the Bengals didn't need help at.

hello 9ers rd 1 pick: Rashaun Woods

2 teams later and he's not even in the NFL

That ugly dirtsack fat guy probably.

I was wondering when someone would catch that.

2nd overall - Robert Gallery OT Raiders

Ahmad Carrol for use :x

It's not even close. Gallery was the "safe pick" in that draft. I think he can still be a good player, but he isn't a LT, hopefully he can get a new start some where else.

I don't think Eli can be considered a bust yet, its gotta be Gallery.

Suprisingly, the Cardinals actually made a good pick in that draft. The Colts' trade down was great as well.

Gallery is definitely the biggest bust of that draft. A lot of players taken in that draft have had very inconsistent, frusturating careers. Players like Mike Jenkins, Michael Clayton, Perry, Veron Carey, and Jason Babin have shown flashes but haven't been consistent, some of them because of injuries.

Rasuan Woods

Gallery.

Reggie Williams started out great, then fell of the face of the earth when Garrard came in. He had a good game last week.

He's never going to live up to the ninth pick billing, but he'll be a good player.

Gallery takes the cake

QFT

I'd say Woods or Robert Gallery.

Chris Perry shouldnt even be on this list he hasnt had a chance. I'd say Gallery but eli isnt that far behind.