2011 Best Draft in Divison
1(27). CB Jimmy Smith Colorado
2(58). WR Torrey Smith Maryland
3(85). OT Jah Reid Central Florida
4(123). WR Tandon Doss Indiana
5(164). CB Chykie Brown Texas
5(165). DE Pernell McPhee Mississippi State
6(180). QB Tyrod Taylor Virginia Tech
7(225) RB Anthony Allen Georgia Tech
1(4). WR AJ Green Georgia
2(35). QB Andy Dalton TCU
3(66). LB Dontay Moch Nevada
4(101) OL Clint Boling Georgia
5(134) S Robert Sands West Virginia
6(167) WR Ryan Whalen Stanford
7(207) CB Korey Lindsey Southern Illinois
7(246) RB Jay Finley Baylor
1(21) DT Phil Taylor Baylor
2(37) DE Jabaal Sheard Pittsburgh
2(59) WR Greg Little North Carolina
4(102) TE Jordan Cameron USC
4(137) CB Buster Skine Tennessee Chattanooga
5(150) OL Jason Pinkston Pittsburgh
7(248) S Eric Hagg Nebraska
1(31) DE Cameron Heyward Ohio State
2(63) OT Marcus Gilbert Florida
3(95) CB Curtis Brown Texas
4(128) CB Cortez Allen Citadel
5(162) LB Chris Carter Fresno State
6(196) OL Keith Williams Nebraska
7(232) RB Baron Batch
I like what Cincinnati, Baltimore, and Cleveland did. I was not real high on Pittsburgh as i was on the other but they had a decent draft. I am going to be a homer and pic the Bengals
i find it laugable that cincy thinks andy dalton is the future.
steelers draft was incredible to me, but you cant argue with what cleveland did by trading out of the 6th pick and still coming away with premium talent, hughe needs, and extra picks. it hurt me to see greg little become a brown
id say cleveland, pittsburgh, baltimore, cincy...landing AJ green becuase they were terrible a year ago isnt enough for me to call cincy a good draft
In any case, here are my thoughts:
I give props to the Bengals for taking A.J. Green. Arguably the best receiver since Calvin Johnson, he could truly be an offensive game-changer for the Bengals. Andy Dalton, eh, definitely not a franchise quarterback for me, nor a guy I would rebuild my offense around, but I can understand why the Bengals took him. Moch is a solid pick, fantastic speed, good athlete, average football player. Will need some work but he's got fantastic upside. Clint Boling is a solid addition for the O-line, where the Bengals need some work. Robert Sands I'm not too crazy about, especially as a free safety. I could understand placing him as a strong safety due to his size and hitting ability, but as a free safety, I'm not too sure. It could be that I'm not entirely sure how free safeties play in Cincy's defense, but if he's asked to be a centerfield/roam a lot, I strongly believe he'll fail. Whalen I know nothing about, and both Lindsey and Finley are probably nothing more than training camp bodies and practice squad candidates, but I'll give them the benefit of the doubt.
Regarding Cleveland, some picks were a bit of a question mark to me scheme-wise, but definitely not quality-wise. Phil Taylor will be a good nose tackle for Cleveland, but if they are switching to a 4-3 defense, who's going to provide any interior pass-rush? I'm guessing that Taylor and Athyba Rubin will be the two tackles, and while they'll be amazing vs. the run, the pass-rush could potentially be very limited. Still, not a bad pick at all, I give props to the Browns for starting to turn things around these past two years. Jabaal Sheard is another solid pick for the new D-Line. Greg Little was probably my favorite pick for the Browns, he's going to be a perfect fit for their offense, IMO. McCoy doesn't exactly have a rocket launcher for an arm, which makes it all the more important to acquire receivers that can gain yards after the catch, which is exactly what Little can do. Similarly to Andy Dalton, I'm not completely sold on McCoy as a future QB, but he played well enough last year to give him another year and gauge his development. Jordan Cameron was a solid pick, filled a need. I hate the Browns for taking Marecic, I just love the way the guy plays football. Having him block for Peyton Hillis could be devastating for opposing offenses, two big runners who clearly aren't afraid of contact. Buster Skrine, don't know much about him, Pinkston could become solid guard depth, and Eric Hagg is probably just training camp fodder/PS material.
Baltimore had a fantastic draft, much to my disappointment, haha. Jimmy Smith is an elite CB prospect from what I see on the field. Off the field, sure there are some issues, but if there is someone who'll be able to keep him in check, it's Ray Lewis, so I guess it's a good fit both ways. Torrey Smith is exactly what this team needed at receiver, a guy who can stretch the field. Jah Reid is a good candidate to replace Gaither. Certainly has the size for it. Tandon Doss could be a fantastic complement to Smith. Chykie Brown and Pernell McPhee are good candidates for development, and IMO will be good depth for the Ravens. Tyrod Taylor is a development prospect, and Allen could be a solid late round pick. I always thought he was an above average runner at GT, could be molded to be a complement to Rice in the upcoming years.
As for the Steelers, Heyward was a fantastic pick for us. I truly believed he was an elite five technique even before he was drafted by us, I just got really excited when we picked him. Gilbert is a pick that addressed a big need, as we've got absolute garbage for depth at OT, and the starters aren't really anything to brag about either. The last time we took a tackle in the second round we wound up with a LT for over seven years, so I hope history repeats itself. In any case, he's quality depth. Brown is another good pick for us, third pick in a row that fills a need and was a good value pick at the same time. Not necessarily an elite prospect, but he is a fantastic athlete and will probably become a solid starter down the line. Nothing spectacular, but solid. At worst, he'll stick as a nickel back, IMO. Allen is raaaaaaaw, very raw as a CB. Got high hopes for him, actually higher than Brown, but not high expectations, if that makes any sense. Carter was a steal, good fits for both sides, but will rarely see the field, IMO. He's behind Harrison and Woodley, as well as Worilds and Timmons. Chris Williams is more O-line depth, a mauler who can pull well, but his upside as a pass-protector is limited, IMO, and is basically a new version of Chris Kemoeatu. Baron Batch is another training camp body, could stick as a third down back if the team doesn't want to retain Mewelde Moore, but will likely stay on the PS for a year or two.
I guess I'd say Baltimore had the best draft, great talent and definitely filled needs.
Pick by pick...
Overall I'll project the Browns did more to change/support their on field play and personality. Followed by Pitts, Baltimore, then Cincy (contingent on Dalton). But if I'm wrong about J.Smith and T.Smith then I def like Bmore's class the best.
browns traded out of their pick and the falcons sold their soul to them, they drafted a big NT, a STUD wr in the second round and they got a DE too. they really helped themselves.
baltimores isnt too great but they got a big corner, exactly what they were looking for and a WR to stretch the field...after that there is some questionable picks but they addressed their two biggest needs.
and the steelers addressed their 3 biggest needs in the top 3 rounds, not sure id say corner was hands down their biggest one but it need need to be addressed. great value in all 3 top picks and then excellent value in carter in the 5
i just dont get how you can rationally look at the 4 drafts and think the bengals are the best of the bunch, dont get me wrong i love the steelers draft i actually cant remember being this happy about a draft class but im impressed with the load cleveland was able to bring in
I am only saying the Bengals because they got 4 day 1 starters in this draft.
Of course AJ Green is going to start and be a stud.
Andy Dalton is basically going to be handed the job unless they sign a vet.
Clint Boling will start at Guard because the starting Guards suck
Robert Sands will also start because the Bengals safeties suck also.
Moch could win the SLB position when they move Maualuga inside.
So that could be 5 starters from day 1. How they pan out idk but getting 5 starters in 1 draft is pretty damn good not matter who u are.
Sadly I think that every team did pretty good. The Ravens draft heavily relies on if the can make J. Smith focus on football and not screw around. I think that strong veteran leadership will help keep him focused. I do like that Smith has a chip on his shoulder from the draft though.
The entire AFCN did a good job in this draft. It's hard to say who did the best because I see 3-5 players from each teams draft class playing big roles on their respective teams.
I agree. On second thought I didn't think that fully through. I think that the perception of this draft is heavily relied on how Jimmy turns out. People either think that this draft was just okay because they dislike Jimmy, or they think we got a top 10 talent and it was a great steal.
Torrey also has a good amount of risk but was a good pick. I think that Reid was an excellent pick and should step in very soon to the RT spot when Gaither leaves. I thought we got good value pretty much trough out while still hitting some needs.
The Browns had the best draft. They ROBBED Atlanta and still added very solid players who fit the AFC North playing style in Little(next Brandon Marshall?), Cameron, Taylor and Sheard. They also set themselves up very nicely for next years draft.
However, I voted Baltimore, I think they came in a close 2nd.
Jimmy is a potential shutdown corner, just needs to stay focused and motivated.
Tandon and Torrey were two great picks. They compliment each other nicely and look for them to be our future tandem at WR.
Reid is a guy that I don't know much about but I don't think the front office would have traded up in the 3rd to get some developmental or backup type tackle. They obviously believe that Reid can start at RT in this league. Let's hope they are right.
McPhee is someone that I think can contribute immediately at the 5 tech rotation. I believe many of his weaknesses are coachable and I could see him becoming the next late round gem of Ozzie Newsome's draft.
|All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:38 PM.|
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.