Draft Countdown Forums

Draft Countdown Forums (http://www.draftcountdown.com/forum/index.php)
-   Pro Football (http://www.draftcountdown.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   The "What If?" Thread (http://www.draftcountdown.com/forum/showthread.php?t=57189)

The Alex 08-12-2013 12:30 AM

The "What If?" Thread
 
This similar to the "Who had greatness derailed by injuries" thread. It's a simple concept - What if things were different? What do you think would have happened if certain players had fulfilled their potential or weren't so quickly abandoned in favor of others? What if certain players chose one team over another in free agency?

For instance, what could have happened to David Carr if Texans didn't have a trash offensive line? What would have happened if Eli had stayed in San Diego with Rivers going to the Giants? What if Deion had stayed in San Francisco?

I'll start with one that always bugs me:

What if Randall Cunningham had proper coaching in Philadelphia?



I honestly think the Eagles would have become the early dynasty of the 90s instead of the Cowboys. They already had the lethal defense and with a properly developed and coached offense, in particular Randall, the team could have easily had multiple Super Bowl appearances. We saw what Cunningham was able to do with competent offensive management in Minnesota, but by then his scrambling days were long gone. Just imagine what he could have done in Philadelphia when he still had his legs. Buddy Ryan screwed us all out of watching something truly special.

BarackSays 08-12-2013 12:36 AM

I could go on for hours about Cunningham, and the 98 season in general.

What if Gary made the kick?

What if Robert Griffith didn't drop the INT on the Falcons' last drive?

What if Randy had caught that bomb Randall threw in OT?

What if Denny Green wasn't the stupidest man on the planet?

People argue that the Broncos would have beaten us anyway, and they probably would have, but it sure would have been a helluva lot better than the squash we got.

Randall was like Mike Vick if Vick lived up to the hype, and even then, he still didn't reach his full potential since Buddy Ryan would eliminate offense from the game if he was allowed. His 1990 season was incredible and I'm shocked he didn't win the MVP that year (won it in a few other publications but not the AP MVP).

Mufasa 08-12-2013 12:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Alex (Post 3423564)
For instance, what could have happened to David Carr if Texans didn't have a trash offensive line?

Would have been a slightly less ****** QB. Think Matt Cassel.

Quote:

What would have happened if Eli had stayed in San Diego with Rivers going to the Giants?
Their careers would probably relatively similar to how they are today. Manning probably could have won a Super Bowl with one of those talented Chargers teams, while Rivers got some playoff appearances out of the Giants

Quote:

What if Deion had stayed in San Francisco?
Honestly, a little before my time watching the NFL. I won't even pretend like I have some insight, 'cause I don't.

The Alex 08-12-2013 12:39 AM

Mufasa, those were example questions for people a little slow to understand the premise, you don't HAVE to answer them.

Mufasa 08-12-2013 12:47 AM

I know, but since you listed them I thought I'd answer them. It'd be pretty boring if this thread was filled with a million questions with no one giving their opinions on what would actually happen

The Alex 08-12-2013 12:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mufasa (Post 3423571)
I know, but since you listed them I thought I'd answer them. It'd be pretty boring if this thread was filled with a million questions with no one giving their opinions on what would actually happen

Fair enough. I actually think Carr would have been decent. Then again, Cassel had a couple decent seasons so you may not be far off.

fatso 08-12-2013 12:53 AM

What if the niners draft Rodgers over Smith? Is Nolan still a head coach? Is Rodgers still elite? Where's Harbaugh?

What if Flacco gets intercepted vs Denver? Who you guys got for the Super Bowl?

Do the Saints make the playoffs last season if bountygate didn't happen?

How high would Aaron Hernandez' body count be if he was drafted by Cincinnati?

What if they got rid of the defenseless receiver rule? Who would benefit , and who would suffer?

BarackSays 08-12-2013 01:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fatso (Post 3423575)

How high would Aaron Hernandez' body count be if he was drafted by Cincinnati?

I'm dying, 10/10

49erNation85 08-12-2013 01:01 AM

What IF this thread never started. Think of that one.

The Alex 08-12-2013 01:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 49erNation85 (Post 3423582)
What IF this thread never started. Think of that one.

We wouldn't have that amazing Aaron Hernandez line.

Obviously, the point of the thread is to get people speculating but try to answer your own or other's questions.

jayceheathman 08-12-2013 01:11 AM

My favorite is, "What if the Lions would have drafted Andre Johnson instead of Charles Rogers?" I'm so glad they didn't. Andre was my favorite player that year in college football and wanted him falling to the Texans. Andre Johnson and Megatron would be ridiculous though.

Mufasa 08-12-2013 01:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jayceheathman (Post 3423586)
My favorite is, "What if the Lions would have drafted Andre Johnson instead of Charles Rogers?" I'm so glad they didn't. Andre was my favorite player that year in college football and wanted him falling to the Texans. Andre Johnson and Megatron would be ridiculous though.

But see, having Andre would very likely make the Lions just good enough to not have a shot at getting Calvin. That's what makes these questions so difficult if you really think about it. There are sooo many variables in there. Step on a butterfly, man

Brothgar 08-12-2013 01:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jayceheathman (Post 3423586)
My favorite is, "What if the Lions would have drafted Andre Johnson instead of Charles Rogers?" I'm so glad they didn't. Andre was my favorite player that year in college football and wanted him falling to the Texans. Andre Johnson and Megatron would be ridiculous though.

If they drafted Andre Johnson they probably wouldn't have Calvin lets not forget that there was significant want for Gaines Adams within the coaching staff that year..

jayceheathman 08-12-2013 01:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brothgar (Post 3423590)
If they drafted Andre Johnson they probably wouldn't have Calvin lets not forget that there was significant want for Gaines Adams within the coaching staff that year..

I was thinking that too. If they had Andre, and still drafted in that same position, then they probably would go in a different direction than WR.

FUNBUNCHER 08-12-2013 01:46 AM

Many analysts cite the death of Eagles quarterbacks coach Doug Scovil in 1989 from a heart attack as the point when Randall stunted in his development as potentially one of the best QBs to play the game.

Scovil is the one credited as most responsible for developing Cunningham into a pro bowl caliber NFL passer.

If Buddy Ryan gave a damn about the offensive side of the football and brought in a REAL OC instead of that bum Rich Kotite, rather than give the ball to Randall and basically tell him to 'make something happen', who knows what could have been in Philly in the the mid 1980s- early '90s.

That team was loaded and a beast on defense.
IMO those Eagles era teams should at least have made an appearance in the SB.

Brothgar 08-12-2013 01:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fatso (Post 3423575)
What if the niners draft Rodgers over Smith? Is Nolan still a head coach? Is Rodgers still elite? Where's Harbaugh?

What if Flacco gets intercepted vs Denver? Who you guys got for the Super Bowl?

Do the Saints make the playoffs last season if bountygate didn't happen?

How high would Aaron Hernandez' body count be if he was drafted by Cincinnati?

What if they got rid of the defenseless receiver rule? Who would benefit , and who would suffer?

If flacco gets picked it becomes manning vs brady pt 10000000 but I think NE takes it assuming Gronk doesn't get injured. Then Pats vs San Fran is tough I think Pats. Also Joe Flacco doesn't make nearly as much money.

Yes saints make the playoffs without bountygate

The Seahawks would really benefit from no defenseless receiver.

BarackSays 08-12-2013 02:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FUNBUNCHER (Post 3423594)
Many analysts cite the death of Eagles quarterbacks coach Doug Scovil in 1989 from a heart attack as the point when Randall stunted in his development as potentially one of the best QBs to play the game.

Scovil is the one credited as most responsible for developing Cunningham into a pro bowl caliber NFL passer.

If Buddy Ryan gave a damn about the offensive side of the football and brought in a REAL OC instead of that bum Rich Kotite, rather than give the ball to Randall and basically tell him to 'make something happen', who knows what could have been in Philly in the the mid 1980s- early '90s.

That team was loaded and a beast on defense.
IMO those Eagles era teams should at least have made an appearance in the SB.

They had the unfortunate timing of the 90s Cowboys, and the fact that the year that was supposed to be THE year for them (1991), Randall tore his ACL in the first game ala Brady and they had to give the reins to Jim McMahon.

Also, never heard that Scovil tidbit before, that's really interesting.

stlouisfan37 08-12-2013 02:06 AM

What if Mike Martz didn't become absolutely obsessed with getting absolute perfection and winning everything RIGHT NOW? Does he have more patience with Kurt Warner's injury, and not send him packing to New York? If Warner stays in St. Louis and revives his career, I think the Greatest Show may have had another Super Bowl in them, and we may have never had to live through Linehan and/or Spags.

Mufasa 08-12-2013 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stlouisfan37 (Post 3423597)
What if Mike Martz didn't become absolutely obsessed with getting absolute perfection and winning everything RIGHT NOW? Does he have more patience with Kurt Warner's injury, and not send him packing to New York? If Warner stays in St. Louis and revives his career, I think the Greatest Show may have had another Super Bowl in them, and we may have never had to live through Linehan and/or Spags.

I don't know about another Super Bowl, but they probably could have at least contended for a while. Kurt's career had he kept his job is a prett interesting one in itself. Right now he's still a borderline Hall of Famer. If he didn't spend a few years as a backup he'd have to be a lock

stlouisfan37 08-12-2013 02:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mufasa (Post 3423599)
I don't know about another Super Bowl, but they probably could have at least contended for a while. Kurt's career had he kept his job is a prett interesting one in itself. Right now he's still a borderline Hall of Famer. If he didn't spend a few years as a backup he'd have to be a lock

I agree. He has great numbers when you take into consideration that he started late and sat for some time. But he doesn't have the whole longevity thing going for him.

Ultimately I think he does get in, I'm just not sure it is a first ballot slam dunk. What he did as far as taking two dead franchises and making them legitimate should help his cause a lot, as well as the fact that he has been great for every community he has been a part of and a great example for people of faith. In the end I think the voters will want him in for the final stamp on his journey.

One interesting tidbit...Warner, Holt, Bruce and Pace will all be eligible in 2015. Pace seems like a first ballot guy to me. Warner I think will get in at some point. Holt and Bruce I don't think get in, not early anyway. Bruce has a better shot than Holt.

stlouisfan37 08-12-2013 03:11 AM

My last post brought me to another thought...have teammates ever been inducted to the Hall in the same year?

AntoinCD 08-12-2013 04:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stlouisfan37 (Post 3423604)
My last post brought me to another thought...have teammates ever been inducted to the Hall in the same year?

Pace is a sure fire first ballot guy IMO. Holt and Bruce may have a tougher time getting in as WR is such a tough position to get in for the Hall.

Warner is an interesting study. Based on 4 or 5 years of play he is a nailed on bet for the hall but for whatever reasons the rest of his career he was a JAG. Without trying to downgrade his achievements if it were up to me he wouldn't get in because the Hall to me is about sustaining greatness throughout your career

7DnBrnc53 08-12-2013 08:22 AM

What if Vick would have been found out in February 2007?

Schaub would still be a Falcon, which means that Matty Ice would be somewhere else (like with the Jets, Chiefs, or Ravens, who had the eighth pick that year before trading down).

Also, maybe the Texans would have traded for Jake Plummer with Schaub off the market, and he plays for them and doesn't retire.

jth1331 08-12-2013 08:24 AM

First, Torry Holt has little to no shot at making the HOF.
What if Terrell Davis doesn't shred his knee in 1999 :(

MassNole 08-12-2013 08:59 AM

What if the Jets take Emmitt Smith #2 in the 1990 Draft over Blair Thomas and Thomas ends up falling to Dallas where they originally took Smith.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:44 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.