Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain
Umm... I love Rodgers as our QB but Favre has had more than 4 good seasons under his belt.
Don't forget Favre helped turn around the franchise. He also won 3 consecutive MVPs and is the only player to ever do so. Led the team to 2 Super bowls and won one.
Favre was also a colossal choke artist and a turnover waiting to happen. Being a complete and total doucher, while largely irrelevant, likely factored into his atrocious decision making.
As for the league MVPs, meh. The one he split with Barry should have been Barry's outright. Hard to put much stock in a popularity contest anyway. John Madden probably stuffed the ballot box that year.