Community Mafia Game Thread- Day Seven- Pg. 62- GREENDALE WINS!

[Gay Ork Wang]

what we do is, you investigate him, then we kill him. easy peasy

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

If you use it one me I can tell you for sure if you get reversed results or if all your results are evil no matter what. Of course there is the possibility that a framer exists but I'm willing to take the chance. I'll just come out with it and tell you I'm a miller. I figure this is the only way I can help the town and if I were to be investigated later on and came back evil no one would believe me and so I'm coming out now.

Once again, no amount of investigations will tell us FOR SURE what Vidae is. As a miller, you are supposed to come back as evil. So if you come back as good, it certainly looks like he just gets reversed results. However, there is still a chance that he gets random results.

And if you come back evil, it certainly looks like he gets all evil. But there is still a chance that he gets all random results. Or you could have been framed. Each investigation makes us a little bit more sure, but we can never be 100% confident.

[SuperMcGee]

I don't want to say too much on it because it ties directly to me, but I do agree that this lynch may not not the best way to figure out vid's results. That said, I have thought you were pretty sketchy in this game and am quite alright with you being lynched today.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Take it for what you will.

I saw an opportunity to help the town with my role and I took it. I imagined I would be investigated and lynched somewhere down the line for coming back as evil so I will take one for the team here to help us clear up the nature of vidae's investigations. By coming out now when the heat was clearly on other people I hope you can believe me but the most I can ask is that you investigate me tonight and decide my fate another day so we can get to the bottom of this incompetent cop business.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

what we do is, you investigate him, then we kill him. easy peasy

That's what we're doing with JR and you're against it.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

Take it for what you will.

I saw an opportunity to help the town with my role and I took it. I imagined I would be investigated and lynched somewhere down the line for coming back as evil so I will take one for the team here to help us clear up the nature of vidae's investigations. By coming out now when the heat was clearly on other people I hope you can believe me but the most I can ask is that you investigate me tonight and decide my fate another day so we can get to the bottom of this incompetent cop business.

I'm glad you did. I feel I can believe you. I just don't want people thinking that the investigation of you locks in stone what Vidae actually is.

[sbh15]

to be honest, my vote for you is more based on what I've picked up than what vidae has said

[Gay Ork Wang]

Originally Posted by vidae

That's what we're doing with JR and you're against it.

yes but he isnt bad. if he shows up good, there still is the possibility of you having all evil and random.

he says he is evil.

If you get evil, you prolly get all evil. If you get good, you prolly get random.

But onyl when we lynch him. He either is a miller or lying about it.

The difference is that we know he is going to come out as evil.

He has no reason to pose as a miller if he is a townie.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by vidae

That's what we're doing with JR and you're against it.

Of course I'm against it. I know I'm good. I don't want the town to waste a lynch on me when they could be going after the killers.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

So you're just a townie? That rules out miller I suppose. Only explanations left are framer and incompetent investigator but those are a lot less likely than vidae's info being right. My vote stands...

I made this post yesterday when BD claimed townie. I was trying to undertsand why he came back as evil if he was just a townie but my role explicitly states miller so that wasn't the case.

I'll let you guys form your own conclusions but I would prefer to stay alive as long as possible haha.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by sbh15

to be honest, my vote for you is more based on what I've picked up than what vidae has said

Please tell me what I have done that is suspicious. I will gladly answer any question you may have so long as it is allowed in the rules.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

Of course I'm against it. I know I'm good. I don't want the town to waste a lynch on me when they could be going after the killers.

I was talking to Renji, not you.

And who are the killers? What other information do we have to go on? Would you rather we no lynch vote? This is all the information we have to go on.

In other games (the Sesame Street game being the most recent) I gladly accepted being lynched if it meant the town got more info. I understand wanting to live, but we have NOTHING ELSE TO GO ON.

Unless you know who these "killers" are, then tell us and we'll lynch them.

[Gay Ork Wang]

idk, id rather kill someone im unsure about like ATL, McGee or ngata, then someone i feel like is good like jrd.

[sbh15]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

Please tell me what I have done that is suspicious. I will gladly answer any question you may have so long as it is allowed in the rules.

half-heartedly defending Bulldogs yesterday and your hesitance to lynch him. something about the way you played on the first day and the way you tried to stop a Gonzo lynch train. not that killing Gonzo because he's crazy was something I found to be a good idea, but there was just something that stuck out about it to me. then when Gonzo also half-way trusted Bulldogs, it sort of lumped the three of you together in my mind.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by vidae

I was talking to Renji, not you.

And who are the killers? What other information do we have to go on? Would you rather we no lynch vote? This is all the information we have to go on.

In other games (the Sesame Street game being the most recent) I gladly accepted being lynched if it meant the town got more info. I understand wanting to live, but we have NOTHING ELSE TO GO ON.

Unless you know who these "killers" are, then tell us and we'll lynch them.

All the discussions today have been about me so it's kind of hard to know who the killers might be. But trust me. I promise I'm good. Use that promise to get the information you want rather than killing me, seeing I'm good, allowing the mafia and serial killer to kill two more, and then using the information you get from me coming back good.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by sbh15

half-heartedly defending Bulldogs yesterday and your hesitance to lynch him. something about the way you played on the first day and the way you tried to stop a Gonzo lynch train. not that killing Gonzo because he's crazy was something I found to be a good idea, but there was just something that stuck out about it to me. then when Gonzo also half-way trusted Bulldogs, it sort of lumped the three of you together in my mind.

I wanted to stop the Gonzo train because I hate the little grudges we have in these games. Yes, Gonzo can rub people the wrong way. Yes, Gonzo ****** up in the DDN game (but so did the town by believing his editorials). But that has no bearing on the Community Game. And lynching Gonzo just because Gonzo is an easy cop-out for a mafia member to use if he comes back as good.

[njx9]

hooray work stuff. having read through the last several pages, i think lynch jrd gives us the most information. lynching caddy or gonzo is silly.

vote: jrdrylie

[Cigaro]

Vote Count:

jrdrylie (9)- TACKLE, SP, sbh, vidae, Ngata, ATL, Gonzo, FE, njx
Gonzo (2)- Todd, Caddy
ATL (1)- Renji
sbh (1)- CJ
FE (1)- Grizz

With 18 alive, 10 are needed for a majority.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

Since I just read through all of the last day, it seems the two people that defended bulldogs the most were SBH and Gonzo. Gonzo kept saying that he would vote for him when it mattered (never did) and SBH kept softly defending him and then saying things like "Obviously this will look bad if he turns up good."

Just two observations.

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

My policy is always one of full disclosure, so Grizz, I also defended Bulldogs a little. As you'll see, I never voted for him. I'm good, I just wanted to be honest with my fellow Human Beings.

Also, would a mafia member do this? Grizz left me out when he mentioned people who supported Bulldogs. I immediately came out honestly and said I supported him too. Why? Because when I'm good, I try to be as honest as possible.

[TACKLE]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

Add sbh to the list of people to look into. Him, Tackle, SP, and Ngata fought hardest for my lynch. I came out with information, trying to clear a guy I think is good, and then they are the conductors of the lynch train.

It was actually McGee who first pointed you out as suspicious. So there are five (and counting) of us all on witch hunt for a simple townie, some of us since day one? A townie who supported and didn't vote against the mafia godfather even after he voted and outed himself. A townie who was defended by someone (TH) who openly said that he believed Bulldogs was good and directly asked people to unvote for him. A townie who made a point of being the posterboy for 'no lynch' on day one yet pushed people to vote for Todd because of inactivity. On the same day you were pushing very hard for that 'no lynch', you make a list of seven suspicious names that people should look into after McGee and I had both suspected you were evil. A townie who knew vidae's results were skewed because he knew his GF shouldn't have come up evil in an investigation. A townie who pretended that he was 99% sure how to interpret vidae's results in a desperate attempt to clear himself and prove he was good when no one had said anything about it since day one. Get over yourself.

JRD, don't take this personally and I think it's because you are playing two games at the same time but you got sloppy in this one.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by njx9

hooray work stuff. having read through the last several pages, i think lynch jrd gives us the most information. lynching caddy or gonzo is silly.

vote: jrdrylie

Once again, lynching me gives you no more information than you already have. I'm good. Use that information to decide what to think about Vidae and who might be evil rather than sacrificing me to learn the same thing but only after two more good guys die (three if you include me).

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Unvote: Gonzo

Vote: JR

[Cigaro]

Final Vote Count:

jrdrylie (10)- TACKLE, SP, sbh, vidae, Ngata, ATL, Gonzo, FE, njx, Todd
Gonzo (1)- Caddy
ATL (1)- Renji
sbh (1)- CJ
FE (1)- Grizz

With 18 alive, 10 are needed for a majority.

[Cigaro]

With their first lynch landing the godfather, the town was optimistic about its chances of nabbing another evildoer. Sadly, they would not succeed. The same voice that first cried out that Bulldogs was evil today declared that jrdrylie was as well. The town thought back to all of the things that jr had been saying the days before and decided there was enough to go on. jrdrylie was a laid back student who spent most of his time hanging outside on campus playing hackey sack and coming up with horrible songs, but his heart was good and he was working to bring to justice the killers of the mascot.

jrdrylie [Vaughn (Townie)] has been lynched.

Night three has begun. Please send in your night actions.

[Cigaro]

Yesterday the school failed to find another culprit, but they were not deterred. However, upon arrival on campus, yet another body was found strewn at the foot of the Luis Guzman statue. This time, it was study group member *** Ork Wang. *** Ork Wang was a very protective mother, and had taken that same attitude towards the rest of the school during these dark times, but the school will now have to do with out her presence.

*** Ork Wang [Shirley (Protector)] has been killed.

Unlike the previous night however, Greendale would not escape with losing only student to the night. A fellow member of the study group, sbh15, was noticed missing. Deantective Pelton quickly drove to her apartment, but there she lay dead. She had clearly been beaten to death by some sort of long rod or something similar, just like the first night's beating victim. Although she was the AT&T of people, she was still committed to finding those responsible for the mascot's murder. She had decided that with her knowledge of psychology, she was as good a candidate as anyone to follow people she suspected to see if she could catch them in the act, but sadly for the rest of Greendale, there will be no more of that.

sbh15 [Britta (Tracker)] has been killed.

Day Four has begun. With 15 remaining, 8 are required for a majority.