Who is the most underrated defensive player on your team?

[XxXdragonXxX]

Originally Posted by tjsunstein

I feel like the terms best and elite are being ver loosely used here. Clemons has 5 sacks on the year, 4 came in one quarter. While its impressive, he seems to get sacks in bunches and stays quiet for a while after. Thats not elite to me.

For the Packers, Im going Jeron McMillan. He's a rookie but he's played very, very well. Or Sam Shields/Ryan Pickett.

While I don't think Clemons gets the recognition he deserves as a pass rusher (thhe pressure he creates is greater than his sack numbers indicate.) The main reason i say he is underrated is that most people think he can't defend the run. Clemons is actually very disciplined in run defense, he's really the only guy on our DL that stays on the field on almost every situation.


However KJ Wright completely slipped my mind, and I would have to agree that he is the most underrated.

[bucfan12]

Mason foster MLB Tampa bay. 11 TFL and second in the nfl in tackles. Beasting it.

[HellonEarth84]

Brandon Spikes. MLB. New England.

[NotMyJob]

Bengals

All three have been mentioned but you can't really go wrong with Geno Atkins, Carlos Dunlap, or Michael Johnson.

Geno is more well-regarded here than in the general public, but Carlos and Johnson are beasts too. Johnson has so much more room to improve it's insane, but he's already a solid DE.

I haven't been more pleased with the defensive line my entire time as a Bengals fan.

...and then there are the backers and safeties.

[themaninblack]

Our pass rush sucks though don't you know this?!

I agree though while I think we could def use some added pass rush help(who doesn't?), I'm happy with the young group we have and it's only going to continue to get better with time. Curious to see how Dontay Moch fits in when he returns as well. Guys got incredible speed which we could use all over the place, his versatility could be very scary as sort of a wildcard to throw out there on passing downs.

[Unbiased]

Derek Cox..

[gpngc]

Originally Posted by tjsunstein

I feel like the terms best and elite are being ver loosely used here. Clemons has 5 sacks on the year, 4 came in one quarter. While its impressive, he seems to get sacks in bunches and stays quiet for a while after. Thats not elite to me.

For the Packers, Im going Jeron McMillan. He's a rookie but he's played very, very well. Or Sam Shields/Ryan Pickett.

You'd be wrong. Those guys play like that every week. You just saw it once and assume incorrectly that was like their best game.

Chancellor is undoubtedly a top safety in the league. And arguably the best true SS in the league.

Since he's come to the Seahawks here are Clemons #s:

2010: 16 GP, 49 tackles, 11 sacks, 1 FF, 4 PD
2011: 16 GP, 50 tackles, 11 sacks, 3 FF, 5 PD

And in three games this year he has 5 sacks, 1 FF, and 3 PD.

Those are elite #s for a 4-3 DE. Put him up against most DEs and I'd guess only three or four have that type of production. Especially impressive considering he's had NO help in terms of other pass rushers until this year.

[Caulibflower]

Originally Posted by gpngc

You'd be wrong. Those guys play like that every week. You just saw it once and assume incorrectly that was like their best game.

C'mon, man. It was their best game. That was as good as anyone's ever seen Seattle's defense. This is precisely why the last call of that game bugs me so much - people are acting like having that many sacks on TNF makes them overrated because they won. If they'd lost, everyone would be talking about how Green Bay won "despite Seattle's stifling defense." Chris Clemons had 4 sacks on primetime. The "reach" pick had two. Don't need to say "That wasn't their best game." Because it was. They're good every week, but from a Seattle fan to another - you're getting a bit hyperbolic here.

[draftguru151]

Paul Soliai or Randy Starks. Both have been fantastic so far this year. Starks a bit more so than Soliai.

[T-RICH49]

Originally Posted by onejayhawk

Tyson Jackson, no question. He is exactly what they wanted when they drafted him #3. Since he plays a 4 tech, 2 gap, with minimal penetration responsibilities, people think he's a bust. Ask a RT that tries to handle him.

J

Nout sure if serious.Jackson is HORRIBLE

[MetSox17]

While a lot of people have learned to recognize Sean Lee, i still don't think he gets the rep he deserves. He's playing at a high, pro-bowl level for us. Just completely eats up the run, gets off his blocks and makes sound, textbook tackles, and is surprisingly good in zone coverage for being an ILB. Still struggles some in man coverage against quick RBs, but he's a complete stud everywhere else.

Another name to keep in mind on our defense is Bruce Carter, our 2011 second round pick. Barely saw the field last year as he recovered from a torn ACL that he suffered at UNC. He battled against Dan Connor in training camp for the vacant ILB spot and handily won the job. He's done nothing but impress so far in his first games as a full time starter. Guy sticks his nose in every run play, and he's one of those guys that hovers to the ball. Just always finds his way. He has been very impressive, and has Cowboys fans holding their breath at the potential the defense has with our completely revamped secondary and the potential for two all-pros and a pro-bowler at LB.

[TitanHope]

Originally Posted by Pit Bull #53

Akeem Ayers. Colin McCarthy makes more splash plays (provided hes actually healthy) but Ayers does it all. He looks fluid in coverage, makes open field tackles, can rush the passer, and knows how to set the edge.

Dude's leading the team in tackles so far. Hopefully, we have Michael Boley 2.0 on our hands. He's just a 2nd year player, so he'll gain notoriety as he goes forward.

For me, I would say DE Dave Ball, but he's never healthy. I thought about CB Alterraun Verner and CB Jason McCourty too, but I think I'm gonna go with DT Sen'Derrick Marks. Before this preseason, I think most people would have labeled him a bust. I know I certainly did, and was why I was clamoring for a DT in the draft. But so far, Marks has not only shown he's an improved player, but he just may be the Titans' best DT. He missed the first two games, but against Detroit, he had 4 solo stops and 6 combined stops. He's a UT, but he might as well be the NT since he's been the strongest at the point of attack going back to the preseason. Other guys may get pushed around, but Question Marks barely moves backward and he still positions himself in the way of the RB so he or another defender can make the stop.

I hope to see his numbers improve as the season goes forward, especially in the pass-rushing department as Jurrell Casey and Mike Martin continue to develop and improve, which will in turn help Marks get to the QB. I'd still love to land a guy like Star Lotulelei in the draft, because getting a Ngata-type freak of a DT is something I think no team should pass up on, but with Marks, Casey, Martin, and Karl Klug to rotate in, I think the Titans have a promising DT group.

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by TACKLE

McCoy has outplayed Suh thus far.

It's a shame he doesn't even get close to the amount of press Suh gets.

[bucfan12]

Originally Posted by Caddy

It's a shame he doesn't even get close to the amount of press Suh gets.

I like it that way. Remember McCoy has history of ending his seasons early. When on the field though he's a beast and dynamic player.

[DanDanE420]

Reshad Jones.

[YAYareaRB]

I think Dashon Goldson is a underrated player on our defense.

[bored of education]

wait for it, wait for it, wait for it.

Tyson Jackson.

Look at the top 15 picks that year in order:
1. Matt Stafford - Lions
2. Jason Smith - Rams
3. Tyson Jackson - Chiefs
4. Aaron Curry - Seahawks
5. Mark Sanchez - Jets
6. Cincinnati Bengals - Andre Smith
7. DHB - Raiders
8. Eugene Monroe - Jaguars
9. BJ Raji - Packers
10. Michael Crabtree - Niners
11. Aaron Maybin - Bills
12. Knowshon Moreno - Broncos
13. Brian Orakpo - Redskins
14. Malcolm Jenkins - Saints
15. Brian Cushing - Texans

Ill be honest. Right now I would take 3 of those picks over Tyson Jackson (minus the fact he is due 14 mil next year, restructure needed). Cushing, Orakpo, Stafford.

Dont give me RAJI, until this year he has regressed each year and has disappeared vs. run and in pass game. Raji is bouncing back this year.


He may not be the best 3rd overall ever but he is far from the worst.

Just look at the entire first round, really. Really gross.

[Bengals78]

Andre Smith has been really good the last 2 years.
But as for the defense, I would say Terrance Newman this year.
He hasn't been bad thus far for a guy playing a lot more than he should.

[tjsunstein]

Just for the record Raji has been completely worth it. He's the only DL that was worth anything until Worthy came in this offseason. Surrounded by dog **** and Clay Matthews in the front 7, its not hard to be keyed in on and ran around. Hes been pretty consistent in getting pressure, too. Not at an elite level but he isnt a ghost out there. And to say youd take Jackson over him? I dont think thatd be smart. Jackson hasnt done half of what Raji has.

[comahan]

This year its Kareem Jackson. He was awful as a rookie and average last year, but he finally looks like he gets it so far this year. Maybe it's Wade coming in, or maybe he just needed time, but he's finally playing up to his pick. Glover Quin deserves recognition too, really solid player.

[jsagan77]

For the skins it's still London Fletcher.. The dude is timeless and SHOULD be compared to Ray Lewis. They have very similar stats, both motivational leaders for their team and have a back to play at a high level for a long time.

#2 is Orakpo... Playing out of position all these years and getting held more than anyone I've ever seen (w/o calls) he's been very good but since he's getting compared to JPP, Ware, and others it's like Skins fans under value him..

[Rosebud]

Originally Posted by jsagan77

For the skins it's still London Fletcher.. The dude is timeless and SHOULD be compared to Ray Lewis. They have very similar stats, both motivational leaders for their team and have a back to play at a high level for a long time.

#2 is Orakpo... Playing out of position all these years and getting held more than anyone I've ever seen (w/o calls) he's been very good but since he's getting compared to JPP, Ware, and others it's like Skins fans under value him..

Are you trying to say that skins fans comparing Rak to JPP and ware...under-rates him?

[holt_bruce81]

For the Rams, it's easily EASILY Bradley Fletcher.

He's given up 7 catches and 44 yards in 4 games. That includes 2 catches for 12 yards vs Megatron. He's a legit shutdown corner when he's healthy.

[YAYareaRB]

also ray mcdonald

[StripedWalrus]

Originally Posted by themaninblack

Our pass rush sucks though don't you know this?!

I agree though while I think we could def use some added pass rush help(who doesn't?), I'm happy with the young group we have and it's only going to continue to get better with time. Curious to see how Dontay Moch fits in when he returns as well. Guys got incredible speed which we could use all over the place, his versatility could be very scary as sort of a wildcard to throw out there on passing downs.

Our pass rush did suck until Dunlap got back.

Dunlap, Atkins, and Johnson are not underrated in my book. I feel they all get their fair share of support, or lack their of in their respected scenario.

The Bengals most underrated player on defense is Thomas Howard. I felt he was out best Linebacker last year and until he went down this year, he was out best backer this year. However, Burfict is playing well in his absence.