You put up a bunch of numbers like its an apples to apples comparison. They are just simply playing in much different offenses and you can't just lump the numbers directly against one another.
I don't buy that either player has a distinct advantage or disadvantage with the players around them. Probably a wash overall to me.
Its a super close race, but I favor Luck because he carries a larger individual burden in my eyes.
That infographic on the last page or so is all kinds funky stats picked out haha. "Most yard gained on zone reads." Aren't there only like 2 or 3 teams that might run zone read plays?