SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by Raiderz4Life

Brody??? lol

10 char.

She was pretty cute if you don't mind making out with a chick that looks a little like Brody, which I'm all cool with.

[Snicho]

Originally Posted by vidae

Oh, this is what you're talking about JR. Yeah, if he is who he is hinting at (the hot sister part) then I definitely know who he is. I dunno what an alarm clock has to do with that, but if he is who I think he is, he wouldn't be evil. Unless it was a mafia safeclaim, but I dunno.

Who do you think he is then?

[Gay Ork Wang]

lynch vidae

Something just seems off. just sentences like

dunno what an alarm clock has to do with that, but if he is who I think he is, he wouldn't be evil. Unless it was a mafia safeclaim, but I dunno.

just isnt something vidae usually does. He doesnt have concrete reasons to vote for people but just "i guess he is suspicious" which isnt really like him. He has been very defensive and i dont think a lot helped the town so far.

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 23 players remaining, 12 votes are needed for a majority

ATL (8) – Todd, Woot, OSU, Rob, CMD, vidae, R4L, Forenci

Vidae (2) - GOW, SuperPacker

CJSchneider (1) - jrdrylie

[SuperPacker]

Well we need to hear what scotty has to say and hope ATL isn't lynched before that happens.

I'm off to bed.

[Raiderz4Life]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

She was pretty cute if you don't mind making out with a chick that looks a little like Brody, which I'm all cool with.

Yea I'm ok with it too, and even more so if I can have a drink or two

[ATLDirtyBirds]

Alright. First off, I've explicitly stated that early in the game (until tomorrow), I wasn't going to have anywhere my normal activity. Using my lack of activity as the reason to vote for me is a cop out, as good or evil, I'm always near the top in participation. I don't do that "laying low" ********. I'm not ******* Forenci.


As far as BB's "subtle defense" of me, I'm really not seeing a defense at all. He's said this in the past about me in different games, and even in his post game commentary as a mod.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Snicho

Who do you think he is then?

I thought he was fenikz, because I remember people making jokes about his sister being hot, but maybe I'm remembering it wrong.

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

lynch vidae

Something just seems off. just sentences like

just isnt something vidae usually does. He doesnt have concrete reasons to vote for people but just "i guess he is suspicious" which isnt really like him. He has been very defensive and i dont think a lot helped the town so far.

I haven't been defensive at all this entire game, even though you've been pointing fingers at me with absolutely nothing.

If you weren't such a bubble butt you'd understand that.

[vidae]

And as far as the alarm clock, if Scotty is fenikz, I don't get what an alarm clock has to do with him. If he isn't fenikz then it could make more sense.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

I always thought he was fenikz. Could be because no daylight savings haha? TBW's theft from me revealing a magnifying glass which I think had more to do with my role than njx so maybe it has something to do with his role? Renji might have shown panties because he was just a townie. In any case I think it's time for a good old fashioned character/role reveal from scotty.

[Gay Ork Wang]

Originally Posted by vidae

I thought he was fenikz, because I remember people making jokes about his sister being hot, but maybe I'm remembering it wrong.



I haven't been defensive at all this entire game, even though you've been pointing fingers at me with absolutely nothing.

If you weren't such a bubble butt you'd understand that.

We all have nothing. i just think my observations are much more than your trains against me, tbw or others

[vidae]

Trains? Now you're saying I've been jumping on lynch trains? You even admitted it a few pages ago that I was the person who initially suspected you, and now I jump on lynch trains?

You're scrambling against me and I really don't get why.

[Gay Ork Wang]

Going hard for TH, then jumping to BD, trying to go with my train. TBW. Many trains you joined or started. none are evil so far.

[Snicho]

Why doesn't Scotty just come out and explain this alarm clock dilemma. Would definitely help.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

I always thought he was fenikz. Could be because no daylight savings haha? TBW's theft from me revealing a magnifying glass which I think had more to do with my role than njx so maybe it has something to do with his role? Renji might have shown panties because he was just a townie. In any case I think it's time for a good old fashioned character/role reveal from scotty.

I'm just throwing this out, but could TBW be lying? He got panties from GOW, which points to his character and we all knew he was a girl. He got a magnifying glass from Todd, which points at his role, not character and we all knew he was an investigator. And now he gets an alarm clock which doesn't make a ton of sense.

So what he stole isn't consistent, doesn't always make sense, and were attributes that were already pretty well known. I'm not saying he is lying, but I'm just not sold on him.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

Going hard for TH, then jumping to BD, trying to go with my train. TBW. Many trains you joined or started. none are evil so far.

Going for TH was the right play. And I'm not the only one who thinks so. And I think it's laughable that when you suspect someone, all of their votes are "lynch trains" but when you think someone is good, they're just regular votes.

Come on Renji.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

I'm just throwing this out, but could TBW be lying? He got panties from GOW, which points to his character and we all knew he was a girl. He got a magnifying glass from Todd, which points at his role, not character and we all knew he was an investigator. And now he gets an alarm clock which doesn't make a ton of sense.

So what he stole isn't consistent, doesn't always make sense, and were attributes that were already pretty well known. I'm not saying he is lying, but I'm just not sold on him.

He revealed mine before I came out and said anything so it checks out. Scotty is probably still drinking away the Louisville game so I think we'll be waiting till later or morning.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by Snicho

Why doesn't Scotty just come out and explain this alarm clock dilemma. Would definitely help.

This would help and so would the other mason coming out. At this point, these days should be shorter and we should be going on more than just our guts. We have cleared four or five people. If scotty and the other mason come out (and since his mason buddy is dead, there is no reason not to) we could potentially have 1/3rd of the game cleared and be very close to solving this mess.

[Gay Ork Wang]

Originally Posted by vidae

Going for TH was the right play. And I'm not the only one who thinks so. And I think it's laughable that when you suspect someone, all of their votes are "lynch trains" but when you think someone is good, they're just regular votes.

Come on Renji.

i dont. i never said that.

but yea, i mean you dont have to understand me. Im just have that feeling you are evil by the way you handle yourself/react to accusations.

[vidae]

How have I handled myself? How have I reacted to situations? How does that scream evil to you?

Two people have accused me of being evil, you and SP, and I can't get a straight answer out of either of you.

Who I am is so flipping obvious that I'm really kind of amazed that I'm suspicious to anyone. Meh, oh well, people are suspicious of everyone else, I'd just like to make it to the end of a game for a change. It's been so long.

[Gay Ork Wang]

This is what i mean. just you being absolutely adamant that you are not suspicious at all and try to totally clear yourself based on nothing.

I always get the feeling from people that try to defend themselves too hard based on one small accusation are usually guilty. but thats just me.

[vidae]

This is not me defending myself hard. This is me just being unsure as to why I'm suspicious.

And you'll note this is the fourth or fifth time I've asked you for a straight answer and you've declined to comment. shrugs, oh well. :)

Hopefully we can get some kind of town consensus tonight so this doesn't drag on all day tomorrow during the games.

[Gay Ork Wang]

ive answered. When called out being suspicious, you directly go into attack, asking "WHY?" and saying "YOU ARE TOTALLY WRONG", when at this point, not being cleared = suspicious. A vote is not a lynch train. But when trains start to catch fire like TH, BD, TBW or me, you were always there.

You have also been not really helpful with your analysis to the town as i consider you being a lot mroe helpful usually in games. It just really reminds me of your Fenrir game you had.

[vidae]

So now asking why someone is voting for you is suspicious? And telling someone they're wrong about you being evil is suspicious? If I didn't address any of the stuff said about me people would say that was suspicious too. It's hard to win with some of this logic sometimes.

But like I said that's fine. I'm not evil, but you have every right to be suspicious of me, even if other members of the town are not.

[Gay Ork Wang]

it depends. every person reacts different. Gonzo will always defend himself hard and accuse the other person to be suspicious.

When you are good, you tend to not care about the early votes/suspicions but get into it when you are catching fire.
But in this game, every time someone mentions your name, you start to ask WHY and that its incredibly bad logic and what not. Like i said, just like when you were Fenrir