Poll: Rookie of the Year (week 16)

[J-Mike88]

We've seen people try and make cases for each of the 3 great rookie QBs, and each have some valid angles, obviously.

Vote time.

Be real here and base it on their production, not how you like them, who was hyped more, who you think will have the better career, longer career, etc.

Production so far as we enter week 16.
Here are the basics, starting with the overall passer ratings.


Robert Griffin, 104.2 (#2 in NFL), 18/4 TD/Int, 2,902 yards passing, 748 yards rushing, 6 TD runs, team is 8-6, tied for 1st in division

Russell Wilson, 95.5 (8th in NFL, right behind Matt Ryan), 2,697 yards, 21/9 TD/Int, 402 yards rushing, 3 TD runs, team is 9-5, current #5 seed

Andrew Luck, 75.5 (30th in NFL), 20/18 TD/Int, 3,978 yards, 233 yards rushing, 5 TD runs, team is 9-5, would be #5 seed

None of the teams was good last year.
Colts were horrible, for the one year, with the Manning loss.
Washington was bad.
Seattle was okay but that offense was stale.

Team Numbers:
Washington has scored 381 points.
Indianapolis has scored 309 points.
Seattle has scored 350 points.

This is a tough vote, but I'll start: My Ballot:

1. Griffin
2. Wilson
3. Luck

What's your ballot look like, who gets your #1 vote?