At this point, what do we make of Peyton Manning's legacy?

[WCH]

Originally Posted by nepg

Thank you for speaking up.

I was sitting there with this face:


The Top 6 is almost undebatable. And I am in the camp that says there are 3 tiers.

Montana/Brady
Elway/Manning
Marino/Favre

Personally, I have it:
Brady
Montana
Manning
Elway
Marino
Favre

That said, I think Manning ends up #2 and Montana #3 for me in the end.

And I love people talking about Brady/Manning as if they're arguing Aikman and Marino where one player clearly had much more amazing team around him his entire career.

This is the post that I agree with the most, but I would also make room (Top 8?) for Tarkenton and Unitas.

Fran Tarkenton, guys! He's not getting enough love!