Originally Posted by BallerT1215
I'm sorry, but I would take McNabb over Warner every single time. I like Kurt a lot, and I think he had some awesome years, but so did Donovan and he never, ever had WR's to throw to like Kurt did.
That being said, he still put up over 37,000 yds and 263 combined TD's in his career. Both are more than Kurt (even if you take out the rushing TD"s, he still has more throwing TD's)
I think you are shorting McNabb a little bit just based off the SuperBowl win that Kurt achieved.
I hate the argument because ultimately it means nothing to the hall of fame voters. Go through every single description of every single hall of fame QB and you won't see "he did have any good WRs." or even "without even having a pro bowl WR". McNabb is Eli Manning without the super bowls. Statistically never in the top 5 save 2004. Never the MVP never won a Super Bowl and there isn't anything special (IE went to four strait super bowls or went to 10 pro bowls) McNabb in the hall opens things up for Drew Bledsoe and half a dozen other QBs.