Originally Posted by Babylon
Derek Carr probably has a better skill set than both guys you mentioned.
From what I've seen, he's naturally talented but it doesn't all fit together. His footwork looks bad; he makes an unusually large jump at the top of his drop. He's routinely falling off his throws instead of stepping in. His level of competition is a flag. His poise under pressure is a concern. He behaves like a douche every now and again on the field when things aren't clicking. And he's got a first round WR helping his stock along with a friendly offensive system.