Vote Here, Whose Better?

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

If that is all you have to say just go home

I am at home thank you, and that is all that i will say too you because if I start to argue with you I will only get frustrated with your Redskins tunnel vision.

Originally Posted by maroney39

I am at home thank you, and that is all that i will say too you because if I start to argue with you I will only get frustrated with your Redskins tunnel vision.

just curious, are you going to annoucne my arrival in every thread

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

just curious, are you going to annoucne my arrival in every thread

hmmmm... I dont remember ever doing this before... can you show me a quote? :? :roll:

Originally Posted by maroney39

hmmmm... I dont remember ever doing this before... can you show me a quote? :? :roll:

Is this gonna be a new thing for you

There he is!!!! . Your a such a flaming homer please dont post in this thread.

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

Is this gonna be a new thing for you

What? That was this thread. :?

[Ward]

Carry on without the personal attacks, maroney has been suspended indefinitely.

[Ho0k Em']

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

I find this quite interesting because over the last 2 years Taylor has been better than Dawkins. Explain how he has not been dominant and since Taylor has been in the leauge do you really think Dawkins has been a better saftey?

Sean Taylor-
Tkl Sack Int FF
60 1 4 2
60 1 2 2

Brian Dawkins-
61...3...4....2
61..3.5....3...4

Taylor has outplayed Dawkins the last 2 years? I think Dawkins has been a better safety.

[Staubach12]

Dawkins

Originally Posted by Ho0k Em'

Sean Taylor-
Tkl Sack Int FF
60 1 4 2
60 1 2 2

Brian Dawkins-
61...3...4....2
61..3.5....3...4

Taylor has outplayed Dawkins the last 2 years? I think Dawkins has been a better safety.

Stats dont tell the whole story, im talkin about big plays in big games, name them

[SeanTaylorRIP]

Coming into this season Sean Taylor for sure, his physical and coverage abilities are unmatched to from any other safety in the league. He doesn't have the same Ed Reed playmaking skills, but they are pretty darn good and near the top of the league matching with his LB like run support.

[sweetness34]

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

I find this quite interesting because over the last 2 years Taylor has been better than Dawkins. Explain how he has not been dominant and since Taylor has been in the leauge do you really think Dawkins has been a better saftey?

Sean Taylor has not been the player I hoped to see when he was drafted. He's had 2 very good years, but with all that talent he can do even more than that.

Brian Dawkins has been one of the top safeties in the NFL for years and years. Sean Taylor needs to prove to me what his upside shows.

Like I said, in a year or two I'll be eating my words and Taylor will be the better Safety, but right now, Dawkins is better.

[Ho0k Em']

How about zero 4th quarter ints, and no ints or sacks when behind.

[turninandburnin1]

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

Stats dont tell the whole story, im talkin about big plays in big games, name them

How bout watching Dawkins just power slam receivers into the ground like its something he does every day. Brian Dawkins is better safety overall, plus he has experience and hes got a straight head on him.

Originally Posted by turninandburnin1

How bout watching Dawkins just power slam receivers into the ground like its something he does every day. Brian Dawkins is better safety overall, plus he has experience and hes got a straight head on him.

Good reasons.....

[jkpigskin]

dawkins! he is smart, aggressive and goooood

only ed reed and troy polamalu are better

[Ho0k Em']

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

Good reasons.....

I usually don't like looking up stats, but....

How about zero 4th quarter ints, and no ints or sacks when behind.

[Paranoidmoonduck]

Dawkins is way more accomplished than Taylor so far in his career, is the undisputed leader on a very complicated and successful defense, and, if we are gonna look at the whole picture, has a much better image as a teammate and person than does Taylor.

Taylor is probably a better athlete than Dawkins ever was or could hope to be, but he has yet to show me he knows his position all that well.

Originally Posted by Paranoidmoonduck

Dawkins is way more accomplished than Taylor so far in his career, is the undisputed leader on a very complicated and successful defense, and, if we are gonna look at the whole picture, has a much better image as a teammate and person than does Taylor.

Taylor is probably a better athlete than Dawkins ever was or could hope to be, but he has yet to show me he knows his position all that well.

What what he have to do to prove that he knows his postion well?

Originally Posted by Ho0k Em'

I usually don't like looking up stats, but....

What about his TD in the 4th to send us to the playoffs, or his TD to win us a playoff game, or in week 2 he hit patrick crayton and made him drop the ball to solidfy our win in Dallas, or the excellent play on the ball he made in the endzone against seattle and then the next play a fumble was forced inside the 5...in the playoffs, or how he stoped jj arrington short on 4th and 2 to give the redskins the W. I can keep going but let it sit in ya mind fam

11-10=1

[Ho0k Em']

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

What about his TD in the 4th to send us to the playoffs, or his TD to win us a playoff game, or in week 2 he hit patrick crayton and made him drop the ball to solidfy our win in Dallas, or the excellent play on the ball he made in the endzone against seattle and then the next play a fumble was forced inside the 5...in the playoffs, or how he stoped jj arrington short on 4th and 2 to give the redskins the W. I can keep going but let it sit in ya mind fam

11-10=1

Alright you got me there I don't get a much of a chance to watch the NFC East and the Redskins play.

There is no doubt in anyones mind that Taylor will be a if not THE elite safety in the league, and after this year he could turn alot of heads. I'm waiting for that potential to soar.

[johbur]

At least you don't worry about Dawkins and firearms... Thank goodness for those multi-million dollar scheister lawyers...

[cunningham06]

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

What about his TD in the 4th to send us to the playoffs, or his TD to win us a playoff game, or in week 2 he hit patrick crayton and made him drop the ball to solidfy our win in Dallas, or the excellent play on the ball he made in the endzone against seattle and then the next play a fumble was forced inside the 5...in the playoffs, or how he stoped jj arrington short on 4th and 2 to give the redskins the W. I can keep going but let it sit in ya mind fam

11-10=1

Well of course Sean Taylor made more big plays in the playoffs considering the Eagles didn't make it to the playoffs this year. :roll:
Dawkins is much better in coverage than Sean Taylor is, is a more sure tackler with better technique(although I will admit that Taylor can light up receivers just as well), and is better on goal line defense. The Eagles have historically been very good in goal line defense, and Dawkins is a major reason why. He takes away the option of bouncing runs outside. Dawkins is also more effective coming off the edge than Taylor is. Dawkins is one of the better blitzing safeties. Dawkins is more versatile, and excels in areas that you expect your safety to. Seriously, Sean Taylor is not better than Dawkins at coverage, and they are about even in run support, so how exactly is Taylor better?

Originally Posted by dcarey20

Taylor is better than Dawkins and in my opinion, Taylor is surprisingly underrated by alot of people...his combo of size and speed is almost unmatched by any other safety in the league. He is one of the biggest hitters in the league but has the ability to cover a slot WR 1 on 1.

Dawkins is a great player and I really really like him, but I think Taylor is better.

Here are my top 5 safety rankings:

1. Ed Reed
2. Sean Taylor
3. Troy Polamalu
4. Brian Dawkins
5. Bob Sanders

Taylor is not better than Troy or Dawkins

Originally Posted by dcarey20

Taylor is better than Dawkins and in my opinion, Taylor is surprisingly underrated by alot of people...his combo of size and speed is almost unmatched by any other safety in the league. He is one of the biggest hitters in the league but has the ability to cover a slot WR 1 on 1.

Dawkins is a great player and I really really like him, but I think Taylor is better.

Here are my top 5 safety rankings:

1. Ed Reed
2. Sean Taylor
3. Troy Polamalu
4. Brian Dawkins
5. Bob Sanders

uhhhhhhhhh, Taylor is not as good as Polamalu, no way you can justify it at all. And Bob Sanders top 5? COuld you not name another safety or were you serious?

[Dam8610]

Neither is a better "saftey". What the hell is a "saftey"?