Doak Walker Finalists announced

Hart, Slaton, McFadden.

Should be interesting to see who gets it.

I want to say Hart, but I have a sinking feeling that since each of the other two have 2 extra games they might get it.

Of course they hate giving underclassmen the award. Remember AD got robbed by Benson 2 years ago?

[elway777]

honestly I cant decide,I just wish Micheal Bush didnt get hurt so he coulda stolen this trophy.

[njx9]

i'd vote slaton, but that's complete personal bias and i've got absolutely nothing to back it up.

[GB12]

Slaton

[smittyjs]

Darren McFadden

[draftguru151]

After McFadden tears up UF, there won't be a discussion.

[SuperMcGee]

Great finalists, tough to choose

I'd like to say Hart, but it might just be McFadden

[srv fan]

This is really tough. All have put up excellent stats for great teams. If I had a gun to my head, I would give it to McFadden. He has been unreal for Arkansas.

[Shane P. Hallam]

Imagine if McFadden had been 100% to start the season...

[rainbeaukid2]

Originally Posted by draftguru151

After McFadden tears up UF, there won't be a discussion.

yes, if he does there would be no doubt

[P-L]

I think it'll depend on Slaton and McFadden's performance. Hart has the trophy now imo, but either one could take it in the next few weeks.

[yourfavestoner]

Originally Posted by draftguru151

After UF's dominant front seven completely shuts down Arkansas' running game, Slaton or Hart will win the award.

Fixed.

McFadden has had a great year, if he was 100 percent week 1 they might of beat USC.....at least played a better game.

[draftguru151]

Originally Posted by yourfavestoner

Fixed.

No chance. And even if he slow him down some, Leak will throw 3 INTs and lose the game.

[thetedginnshow]

I really think McFadden has the biggest impact on his team, and so he should win it, but who knows. They're all deserving. But yeah. If McFadden can light up LSU and Florida, he'd undoubtedly get it.

Mcfadden

[draftguru151]

Originally Posted by HookEm

McFadden has had a great year, if he was 100 percent week 1 they might of beat USC.....at least played a better game.

A better game maybe, but they had no chance to beat them at that point, maybe now, but not then.

[Gribble]

Originally Posted by draftguru151

No chance. And even if he slow him down some, Leak will throw 3 INTs and lose the game.

I think Tebow should start. Leak is unfit for Meyer's offense...

[yourfavestoner]

Originally Posted by draftguru151

No chance. And even if he slow him down some, Leak will throw 3 INTs and lose the game.

Leak botching the game is actually more likely to happen than McFadden running wild, seeing as how Florida's been one of the best run-stopping teams in the country this year. Either way, I'm not super worried. I'd be far more concerned if Florida was playing LSU again than I am about Arkansas and their one-dimensional team.

[draftguru151]

Originally Posted by yourfavestoner

Leak botching the game is actually more likely to happen than McFadden running wild, seeing as how Florida's been one of the best run-stopping teams in the country this year. Either way, I'm not super worried. I'd be far more concerned if Florida was playing LSU again than I am about Arkansas and their one-dimensional team.

LSU's run D>Florida's.

[yourfavestoner]

Originally Posted by draftguru151

LSU's run D>Florida's.

Ok. I could see how that would be a good argument if LSU lost to Arkansas, but they didn't. McFadden had 187 yards and 2 touchdowns, and the Hogs still lost.

Come on, DG, I know you hate Florida, but stop letting it blind you. Florida is significantly more talented than Arkansas at every position except for tailback. The only way they lose is if Leak gives the game away, or if UF's run defense suddenly decides to play like crap, which probably isn't going to happen, as Siler and Everett will be healthy.

[Shane P. Hallam]

And who knows, Arkansas may pass more to the Florida defenders than the Arkansas WRs...

[Javzz]

Originally Posted by yourfavestoner

Leak botching the game is actually more likely to happen than McFadden running wild, seeing as how Florida's been one of the best run-stopping teams in the country this year. Either way, I'm not super worried. I'd be far more concerned if Florida was playing LSU again than I am about Arkansas and their one-dimensional team.

Florida lost their best run-stopping presence..

[SeanTaylorRIP]

That Arkansas wildcat formation is unstoppable I would actually like to see McFadden throw more, heck he throws better than Casey and Mustain.

Originally Posted by draftguru151

Michigans's Run D>LSU's run D>Florida's.

:D