Is Coltson loosing the Rookie of the Year

[Paul]

Originally Posted by SuperMcgee

Young is 6-4 as a starter with the losses coming to teams with a combined record of 36-15, with two of those losses coming by one single point

:shock: :shock: If you were on Around the Horn you get 25pts. that's some good stats.

[4pAc]

Vince Young is Awatham

[Fogartynyy2789]

As much as I love HOFSTRA's Colston, he was never winning the ROY anyway.

[TPFKA#1SaintsFan]

Originally Posted by Fogartynyy2789

As much as I love HOFSTRA's Colston, he was never winning the ROY anyway.

........

[yourfavestoner]

Originally Posted by Fogartynyy2789

As much as I love HOFSTRA's Colston, he was never winning the ROY anyway.

Care to expound on that, or are you just talking out of your ass?

[Mr. Stiller]

Originally Posted by Paul

:shock: :shock: If you were on Around the Horn you get 25pts. that's some good stats.

Isn't vince 6-1 as a starter? I'm pretty sure that Collins started 0-3...

and Colston was the leader.

[njx9]

Originally Posted by Mr. Stiller

Isn't vince 6-1 as a starter? I'm pretty sure that Collins started 0-3...

and Colston was the leader.

vince has started 10 games this season, starting week 3. he's 6-4.

[Fogartynyy2789]

Originally Posted by yourfavestoner

Care to expound on that, or are you just talking out of your ass?

Yes I will.

1. Colston is not a superstar. There is no way people are going to give the award to a seventh round draft pick.

2. Reggie Bush or Marques Colston. Put yourself in the media's shoes. Let's see we can have the most marketbale player in pro football right now or someone who went to school on Long Island and prior to this year nobody had ever heard of.

3. Reggie Bush has "saved" New Orleans along with Drew Brees, according to the media.

4. Vince Young is having a better year than both of them and has resurrected a franchise by himself.

Any questions???

[FlutiesDropKick]

Originally Posted by Fogartynyy2789

Yes I will.

1. Colston is not a superstar. There is no way people are going to give the award to a seventh round draft pick.

2. Reggie Bush or Marques Colston. Put yourself in the media's shoes. Let's see we can have the most marketbale player in pro football right now or someone who went to school on Long Island and prior to this year nobody had ever heard of.

3. Reggie Bush has "saved" New Orleans along with Drew Brees, according to the media.

4. Vince Young is having a better year than both of them and has resurrected a franchise by himself.

Any questions???

yeah one. If antoine agudio went undrafted by the NBA from the same school and had a colston like year you would def be calling for him for ROY. Aside from the man crush, whats differant

[TPFKA#1SaintsFan]

Originally Posted by Fogartynyy2789

Yes I will.

1. Colston is not a superstar. There is no way people are going to give the award to a seventh round draft pick.

2. Reggie Bush or Marques Colston. Put yourself in the media's shoes. Let's see we can have the most marketbale player in pro football right now or someone who went to school on Long Island and prior to this year nobody had ever heard of.

3. Reggie Bush has "saved" New Orleans along with Drew Brees, according to the media.

4. Vince Young is having a better year than both of them and has resurrected a franchise by himself.

Any questions???

1. So the most hyped rookie every year automatically wins rookie of the year? Gimme a break. :roll:

2. Bush is making a case for himself recently. Colston has been spectacular since the beginning of the season.

3. That has nothing to do with the award.

4. Nothing to do with what you originally said. You said Colston never was winning ROY, when actually before he got injured he was the frontrunner by quite a bit. If he finishes up strong, he still is in the running.

[TPFKA#1SaintsFan]

Originally Posted by Fogartynyy2789

1. Colston is not a superstar. There is no way people are going to give the award to a seventh round draft pick.

I'd also like to point out that Mike Anderson won rookie of the year in 2000 as a 6th round draft pick. Where you were drafted has nothing to do with it.

[Jughead10]

Originally Posted by TPFKA#1SaintsFan

I'd also like to point out that Mike Anderson won rookie of the year in 2000 as a 6th round draft pick. Where you were drafted has nothing to do with it.

Dominic Davis won it as well. Was he 3rd or 4th round. Actually I take that back. He won the one voted on by the fans or something.

[TPFKA#1SaintsFan]

Originally Posted by Jughead10

Dominic Davis won it as well. Was he 3rd or 4th round. Actually I take that back. He won the one voted on by the fans or something.

I don't think 2003 was even a competition. Anquan Boldin won it easy.

[eacantdraft]

Originally Posted by Fogartynyy2789

Yes I will.

1. Colston is not a superstar. There is no way people are going to give the award to a seventh round draft pick.

2. Reggie Bush or Marques Colston. Put yourself in the media's shoes. Let's see we can have the most marketbale player in pro football right now or someone who went to school on Long Island and prior to this year nobody had ever heard of.

3. Reggie Bush has "saved" New Orleans along with Drew Brees, according to the media.

4. Vince Young is having a better year than both of them and has resurrected a franchise by himself.

Any questions???

1. Yeah right. Curtis Martin was 3rd round pick. Mike Anderson was a late round pick. They both won ROTY.

2. Bush isn't even the most marketable player in the league, on his team, or in this years rookie class (Vince Young is).

3. Bush hasn't been much of a factor in saving New Orleans.

If Colston doesn't get rookie of the year, it's because he has been injured the past few weeks and other rookies have been making a run for it lately. Plus New Orleans hasn't missed a beat without him. And voters tend to look who was the hottest in the 2nd half of the season. There is still 3 games to go. Alot can change.

[Smooth Criminal]

The reason Colston won't get it is because of the injuries and Vince Young's recent success. People always seem to remember what happens at the end of the year instead of looking at the whole thing when it comes to awards.