Originally Posted by WinslowEdwards19
You would take Cutler and Shaub over Anderson? You're insane.. Look at what he did in his first season as a starter, compared to both of those two.
Garrard is more understandable, but can lean on the running attack more than anything.
Hell yea I would. Anderson rode the back of the leagues best O-line, a top 10 WR, and a top 3 TE...he's got a strong arm but his accuracy sucks and any slight pass rush threw the guy off his game last season.
He's got the potential, but give me Cutler and Schaub over him anyday. Those guys have seen some good coaching, because they're really polished QBs at a pretty young age.
Anderson just seems too inefficent for me...but the talent around him more than makes up for it. With time and practice that could/should change like I said, but if I'm a GM I'm taking more polished guys first.