Is the All Star game in a National League park this year? Is that why there is no DH. If that is the case Giambi should start at 1b. Only player having a better season than him in Thome but he never plays the position.
Honestly, the whole Yankees infield could start the All Star game and it would be pretty fair. No one from their outfield should be there. Although if Damon stays hot like he is now, he could earn his spot, but right now he doesn't deserve to be there.