MLB Discussion Thread

[Hines]

Originally Posted by holt_bruce81

If they get an Innings eater in that rotation, a guy like Dempster or Garza or maybe even Pavano......Wouldn't cost as much as trying to trade for a guy like Hamels, saves that bullpen a bit, they could pull it off.

I want Dempster or Jason Vargas. Saunders and McCarthy would have been nice if they weren't hurt. Garza would cost too much IMO.

[Giantsfan1080]

The Real MVP:

[holt_bruce81]

Originally Posted by gpngc

F that. They need another bat. I just don't what will be available now that everyone thinks their in it because of the extra wild card.

Disagree, I mean they could use another bat but it's not as big of a need as getting another Arm in that Rotation. They did score 146 runs last month, leading the Major Leagues. And guys like Walker, McGehee and Alveraz are actually starting to contribute to the team.

[Smooth Criminal]

I'd love to see another outfielder. Marte will be up right after the break. And while Sutton, Jones, and Harrison have been capable filling in the other spot, I'd much rather see a nice power bat added. My target would be Willingham there.

But I do think adding another starter could make this rotation pretty ridiculous. Burnett and McDonald have been great. Karstens had great stuff tonight and I think he is very efficient and consistent. Bedard has great stuff when he's pitching well. Adding another solid arm could be a great move. Only thing is that arm might just come from AAA where most of the starters are pitching very welll. Might be nice to give one of them a chance before seeing what you need to give up for a rental arm.

Just keep winning series. It's been an awesome first half of the season.

[Hines]

Originally Posted by holt_bruce81

Disagree, I mean they could use another bat but it's not as big of a need as getting another Arm in that Rotation. They did score 146 runs last month, leading the Major Leagues. And guys like Walker, McGehee and Alveraz are actually starting to contribute to the team.

Pirates still need a bat just in case Alvarez doesn't go on one of his huge slumps again. Jones and McGehee would be a nice platoon at first, but in no way should be non-replaceable if a better option comes aboard.

Starling Marte should/will be up after the break. Cody Ross would be a nice addition to the club. I really want Headley, Quentin, or Willingham, but I don't think the Pirates would give up enough to land them.

[Smooth Criminal]

Originally Posted by Hines

Pirates still need a bat just in case Alvarez doesn't go on one of his huge slumps again. Jones and McGehee would be a nice platoon at first, but in no way should be non-replaceable if a better option comes aboard.

Starling Marte should/will be up after the break. Cody Ross would be a nice addition to the club. I really want Headley, Quentin, or Willingham, but I don't think the Pirates would give up enough to land them.

I like Headley a lot as well, mostly because of the years of control. I'd definitely build a package around any of our AAA arms for him if that would've enough to get it done.

Biggest addition to this team would come from getting another quality pitcher. No way we finish the season with Correia as a starter whether the replacement come from AAA or a deadline move.

[Hines]

Originally Posted by Smooth Criminal

I like Headley a lot as well, mostly because of the years of control. I'd definitely build a package around any of our AAA arms for him if that would've enough to get it done.

Biggest addition to this team would come from getting another quality pitcher. No way we finish the season with Correia as a starter whether the replacement come from AAA or a deadline move.

I would dangle Robbie Grossman to teams. He's very solid and is starting to rake after now getting healthy after his hamate injury this offseason. The Padres love athletes and I think he'd be on their list of prospects to grab.


I'd try and trade Owens/Locke for the starter. For some reason, I want to keep Justin Wilson. A lefty who can throw as hard as he can and has the stuff he has is not common. Control is what is holding him back. He could be a pretty good 3rd starter or a dominating closer. Either one would be fine for me.

[Giantsfan1080]

Take this Pirates BS elsewhere.

[Hines]

Regarding Correia:

I want him gone because I don't think he's anything special and I wouldn't trust him if our season was on the line. But he is what he is and does an adequate job at it. He's strictly a 5th starter. He's pitched some nice games lately, but is prone to his blow ups. I'd put Bedard on the DL because he isn't the same pitcher he was after he got those back spasms.

[Giantsfan1080]

Nevermind I'm drunk I feel bad. Sorry Hines and Smooth.

[Hines]

Originally Posted by Giantsfan1080

Take this Pirates BS elsewhere.

I know(I think) you're being sarcastic, but no, I will not. It's the baseball thread and I damn well will talk about the Pirates. If others can talk about Trout, Yankees, Mets, etc all thread long, I can talk about the first place Pirates.

[holt_bruce81]

Originally Posted by Giantsfan1080

Take this Pirates BS elsewhere.

Mets suck. My prediction for RA Dickey the 2nd half....

3-12, 4.65 ERA

[Giantsfan1080]

Originally Posted by Hines

I know(I think) you're being sarcastic, but no, I will not. It's the baseball thread and I damn well will talk about the Pirates. If others can talk about Trout, Yankees, Mets, etc all thread long, I can talk about the first place Pirates.

I already apologized. Check my above post. I'm actually very glad you're doing well!!!

[Giantsfan1080]

Originally Posted by holt_bruce81

Mets suck. My prediction for RA Dickey the 2nd half....

3-12, 4.65 ERA

CAR---LOS BELTRAN!

[Smooth Criminal]

It's even fun to say. First Place Pirates.

And at least you can't say you're sick of Pirates talk over the years...

[Hines]

Originally Posted by Giantsfan1080

I already apologized. Check my above post. I'm actually very glad you're doing well!!!

Yeah I posted that after he posted yours. Didn't see it. Hope to play the Mets for the right to go the the World Series.

[Giantsfan1080]

I'll cream in that case Hines.

[Bixby (Thumper)]

Originally Posted by Borat

Giants will be vastly overpaying for a closer soon. My guess is Huston Street. Probably Posey for Street.

That would be the stupidest trade ever. One of the best catchers in the game for a closer? Shoot, I'd deal Ryan Cook for Buster Posey in a heartbeat.

[holt_bruce81]

Cards win 6-2, take 3 of 4 from the Rockies. Need to take at least 2 of 3 from the Fish so we can go into the break with a little momentum to start the 2nd half.

Cardinals are pretty much on pace to what they were last year

2011: 45-38
2012: 44-39

I'm predicting 91-92 wins will win the Division.

[MaxV]

Pirates are an awesome story. It would be great to see them make the playoffs...











... as long as it's not at the expense of the Mets of course.

[yo123]

Originally Posted by Bixby

That would be the stupidest trade ever. One of the best catchers in the game for a closer? Shoot, I'd deal Ryan Cook for Buster Posey in a heartbeat.

Woooossh...

[Borat]

Somebody fell into the sar-chasm.

[Giantsfan1080]

Originally Posted by Bixby

That would be the stupidest trade ever. One of the best catchers in the game for a closer? Shoot, I'd deal Ryan Cook for Buster Posey in a heartbeat.

Some one is an idiot.

[Bengals78]

Maybin robbed at 1st for sliding head first like a moron. Helps the Reds.
Idiot. Sliding head first is stupid.

[Hines]

Let's go Maybin!