What if Willis McGahee..............

[shylo3716]

What if Willis McGahee never suffered that injury in the National title game, and was a top 5 pick as projected?

[Gay Ork Wang]

what if Grossman didnt suck

[nepg]

What if I didn't have an ingrown hair on my balls?

[shylo3716]

Can you please be serious about this thread. I THINK SKY WOULD HAVE BEEN THE LIMIT FOR HIM.

[fenikz]

he would of went top 5, still had 4.3 speed and put up 30 TD every year like he did at Miami

[Brent]

he would have been a Saint or Cowboy.

[gsorace]

What John Elway decided to play baseball for the Yankees?

[Saints-Tigers]

Don't think he lost as much speed as people like to pretend, and I thought he was overrated before his injury. People love "what if" stories, and they always get played up at least a bit.

[fenikz]

Originally Posted by Saints-Tigers

Don't think he lost as much speed as people like to pretend, and I thought he was overrated before his injury. People love "what if" stories, and they always get played up at least a bit.

so you never watched him play is what youre saying

as a Sophomore

282 Carries, 1753 Yards, 6.2 YPC, 28 TD, 27 Rec, 355 Yards

[Saints-Tigers]

Originally Posted by fenikz

so you never watched him play is what youre saying

as a Sophomore

282 Carries, 1753 Yards, 6.2 YPC, 28 TD, 27 Rec, 355 Yards

Lol yea. Every time I'm not part of the mob, I haven't watched someone. I'm a huge huge fan of the U.

Oh by the way, a lot of guys got those numbers, I learned in the Andre Johnson thread that touchdowns are meaningless, so there isn't anything that special about it.

Larry Johnson was better than Willis even before the injury, and Willis was a pretty good prospect, that turned into a pretty good player. He was overhyped a good bit, and wasn't an Adrian Peterson kind of player.

[PackerLegend]

What ifs are terrible and can be said about any situation. Just avoid them.

[Saints-Tigers]

Willis became what I thought he would be even before the injury, 1100-1200 back, and 4 yards per carry type of dude.

[V.I.P]

What if we coverted on 4th down and won the game today?

[niel89]

He doesn't have this burst anymore.

[RaiderNation]

What if JaMarcus Russell wasnt fat? Oh he would be a horrible skinny QB nvm

[J-Mike88]

McGahee was sensational.
I was overseas during that Title game against Ohio State and couldn't believe when I learned Miami lost to the Buckeyes.

When I saw the highlights of that gruesome hit, I almost puked.

I HATE pussies who tackle like that!
As much as we're seeing helmet to heads cracked down on, I'm also sick of DBs diving into the knees/legs of players like that.

Why don't these DBs tackle like men these days? Very few do.

[San Diego Chicken]

The fact that he came back from that injury and was able to have a decent NFL career is pretty amazing, most thought his career was done. A better "WHAT IF" might be Ki-Jana Carter, probably the last running back to go #1 for quite a while.

[Vox Populi]

Originally Posted by shylo3716

What if Willis McGahee never suffered that injury in the National title game, and was a top 5 pick as projected?

No one would care if Frank Gore didn't blow out his knees.

[Job]

What if Helen Keller wasn't blind and deaf?

[Brodeur]

I think that was Anne Frank.

[Job]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

I think that was Anne Frank.

My mistake. Now I look dumb.

[fenikz]

Originally Posted by Saints-Tigers

Lol yea. Every time I'm not part of the mob, I haven't watched someone. I'm a huge huge fan of the U.

Oh by the way, a lot of guys got those numbers, I learned in the Andre Johnson thread that touchdowns are meaningless, so there isn't anything that special about it.

Larry Johnson was better than Willis even before the injury, and Willis was a pretty good prospect, that turned into a pretty good player. He was overhyped a good bit, and wasn't an Adrian Peterson kind of player.

AD and Willis arent the same type of player, AD could never get close to a 4.2

also please show me someone with a season near as good as that, Bush is the only one i can think of

[A Perfect Score]

Willis before the injury was the best college RB I'd ever seen. Since then, AD has surpassed him, but still...those are the top 2 if you ask me. Willis was absolutely unreal.

[yourfavestoner]

What is it with great Miami backs and horrific knee injuries.

Imagine what Frank Gore, McGahee, and Edge could have been if they never had suffered those injuries.

[Ravens1991]

Wasnt Gore unanimously the best out of all of them but had those terrible knee injuries?