I'm of the opinion that Anthony Adams should be about a 75 and that Peppers deserves one or two more points, but that's quibbling.
If anything, Tillman is about 5 points overrated. Same for Afalava. Sadly, Bullocks is overrated at 69...by probably about 10 points.
Hester is ok. Knox should be equal with him, as he already is in real life. I think Aromashodu at 70 is a product of a grossly wrong speed rating. His 40 time at the combine was 4.35. They must not have looked that up. His rating will probably go up quite a bit with the first update.
Seems ok to me.
Cutler is about 5 points underrated right now. He may pass 90 by the time the year is over with all of the pass attempts he'll get.
Kreutz is overrated, Beekman underrated, but neither of them by a ton.
Roach should be better than Hillenmeyer.
I don't think Maynard deserves to be that high.
All in all, I don't think it's off by too much.