I'd rather have Garrard personally, but either him or Palmer gives us a much better chance at competing for the division title. Boller isn't anything to brag about and it's WAY to early to start Pryor this year. Trading for Palmer will likely cost us another draft pick, like we haven't traded a bunch of those. Garrard will only cost us cap space and will be around the same price as Palmer.
Welcome to the Silver & Mack
"Just Win Baby"- Al Davis