Mafia: Game Ruined

[ATLDirtyBirds]

It's one thing to be given info, but I'm still completely unsure of how you can possibly make a search.


unvote: Shane
vote: Wooty

[Wootylicous]

What the crap ATL ?

Voting for me to be lynched is dumb. I actually came forward and told you guys Deep was bad since the beginning and I have not looking back since then.

[scottyboy]

i think voting to lynch woot now is dumb. it's a waste of a lynch. he's going to be gone soon.

UNLESS, atl wants to protect deep and eatw because they're all in cahoots together in being bad...

[Wootylicous]

I'm gonna investigate his ass next round if I'm not dead by night. This is fischy.

[ATLDirtyBirds]

Originally Posted by Wooty Magic!

What the crap ATL ?

Voting for me to be lynched is dumb. I actually came forward and told you guys Deep was bad since the beginning and I have not looking back since then.

Do tell how you were able to "search" without a night.

[Jensen]

Originally Posted by scottyboy

i think voting to lynch woot now is dumb. it's a waste of a lynch. he's going to be gone soon.

UNLESS, atl wants to protect deep and eatw because they're all in cahoots together in being bad...

Why would Woot be gone soon? I don't think the mafia would kill him right off the bat since he was apparently only Caddy's friend and really provides nothing else unless he keeps getting more info from Caddy.

[eaglesalltheway]

I'm in cahoots with no one, scotty, at least to my knowledge, lol, so you can throw that out the window, lol...

II do think I'm going to roll with Wooty, because he is the one putting everything one the line and he likes the Barr Brothers, but mostly because he likes the Barr Brothers.

vote: Deep

Nothing against you, deep, you seem to be the victim of whatever happened that makes wooty firmly believe you are evil, if you aren't, I'm sure Woot's got some splainin' to do, and idk if the Barr Brothers are enough for me to spare him if he turns out to be lying.

[scottyboy]

Originally Posted by Jensen

Why would Woot be gone soon? I don't think the mafia would kill him right off the bat since he was apparently only Caddy's friend and really provides nothing else unless he keeps getting more info from Caddy.

if he's wrong about Deep, he's probably getting lynched
if he's right about Deep, and Deep's simply "evil", then he won't be gone soon.
but if Deep is mafia, woot is as good as dead

[Raiderz4Life]

Man I just took in a lot of info. I think out best bet for this one would be to take a flyer with wooty.

vote: Deep

[D-Unit]

Originally Posted by DeepThreat

What other defense can I possibly give? I said my role (stinky hobo, not drunk, sorry). It's way too early in the game for me to have anything else to offer.

I guess I missed that... Stinky hobos can be paid off pretty easily to commit evil deeds.

I'm all for cleaning up the streets.

[Job Reborn]

Originally Posted by Wooty Magic!

What the crap ATL ?

Voting for me to be lynched is dumb. I actually came forward and told you guys Deep was bad since the beginning and I have not looking back since then.

It is not that dumb. Lynching you will either a) confirm your story or b) confirm my theory. It is actually the safe choice.

Lynching Deep is more like all or nothing. If you're truthful, we get a mafioso. If I'm right, the town will eventually lynch two non-mafia.

Really just depends on which road the people prefer to take.

[FlyingElvis]

Several of our supposed brethren in this town have yet to make an appearance. I still think we should lynch a no-show. Silence = something to hide.

The Woot/Deep issue is an absolute lead for investigation. Two townspeople we know have some form of pertinent evidence. Lynching either removes a true lead and turns our investigative efforts into a crap shoot.

[Job Reborn]

Originally Posted by FlyingElvis

Several of our supposed brethren in this town have yet to make an appearance. I still think we should lynch a no-show. Silence = something to hide.

The Woot/Deep issue is an absolute lead for investigation. Two townspeople we know have some form of pertinent evidence. Lynching either removes a true lead and turns our investigative efforts into a crap shoot.

Meh. Lynching a no-show is not an option at this point. Deep, Woot or eatw still are the only options I believe. (I think eatw's explanations for voting no-lynch against his principles are not up to snuff. You either believe a no-lynch is not productive, or you don't.)

[diabsoule]

In the face of everything I'm thinking voting for Deep makes the most sense. I'm putting my faith in Woot and then the next night we'll see what an investigation of anyone suspicious will bring.

Vote: Deep

[Shane P. Hallam]

That makes 11 for Deep. 6 more for a lynching.

[Jvig43]

Unvote: No Lynch
Vote: Deep

and if he isn't a mafia I'm going to bring up the fact that I said we should wait.

[eaglesalltheway]

I do think a no lynch is counter-productive, but given the amount of info out there at the time,i wasn't ready to make a decision. I also forgot there are 33 people playing at first and wanted to take pressure off of JBond. I do find it i nteresting I cast suspicion towards you and your response is to try to have me lynched, while you show no evidence to sport your innocence... So can I ask for an explanation from you for your actions? I personally think I've explained myself enough for you to realize I'm not a threat, so I'd appreciate some explanation from you good sir.

Edit: also job, idk if you noticed yet, but I am no longer in favor of no lynch. I'm unsure if Deep is evil, but wooty is CONVINCED, so considering there is no better info to go on right now, it's my most logical choice.

[DeepThreat]

Originally Posted by D-Unit

I guess I missed that... Stinky hobos can be paid off pretty easily to commit evil deeds.

I'm all for cleaning up the streets.

I randomly receive info, which I use for good. I win when the town is a safe place.

[Job Reborn]

Point to a doubtful action and i will readily oblige. I think I pretty much explained every single action I have taken while I was taking it. I might have forgotten something.

Edit adressing your edit : Yes I did notice. Doesn't change the fact I found your course of action rather contradictory.

[Shane P. Hallam]

Off to rehearsal for me, I'll check back in a few hours.

[UKfan]

Why would a hobo randomly receive info, especially a stinky hobo at that? The role and the abilities don't seem to mesh too well there really. Is there more to your back story stinky hobo?

[Job Reborn]

Originally Posted by UKfan

Why would a hobo randomly receive info, especially a stinky hobo at that? The role and the abilities don't seem to mesh too well there really. Is there more to your back story stinky hobo?

A Hobo lives in the streets. Sometimes sees things or overhears things. I used that role when modding once. It does mesh. Though I'm not entirely sure Deep is a hobo.

[DeepThreat]

Originally Posted by Job Reborn

A Hobo lives in the streets. Sometimes sees things or overhears things. I used that role when modding once. It does mesh. Though I'm not entirely sure Deep is a hobo.

This is accurate. But I am a hobo.

[TheBoyWonder22]

I'll go with this. Jvig, your post is acknowledged
Unvote: Job
Vote: DeepThreat

[A Perfect Score]

I miss 12 pages of discussion and not a single night. Excellent. So why exactly are we all voting for Deep? Someone give me a summary, I've been off working for a day.