Mafia: Game Ruined

[Caddy]

Vote Count

No Lynch 9: Cain, Ngata, Rufus, Zach, Jvig, Scottyboy, Vidae, CCB, Goose
Deep 1: Wooty
Cain 1: Job
Shane 2: ATL, JoeJoeBrown
Job 1: The Boy Wonder,
UKFan 1: Bulldog

[TheBoyWonder22]

I explained the reasoning a page back but I'm gonna go with Job. He did accuse IBC for something that is very normal. Kind of a reach. I'll probably change my vote, but this seems suspicious.
Unvote: No Lynch
Vote: Job

[zachsaints52]

I am not part of the mafia.

Sorry, just got back from a quiz show about Black History Month.

[Bulldogs]

Vote: UKfan

No other reason than to stir up the pot and hear some thoughts.

[TheBoyWonder22]

He just isn't active. That would be seen more as suspicious than anything FYI.

[eaglesalltheway]

Jbond,i was just trying to spark up debate. I figured you'd feverishly defend yourself and would either prove to be good, which I think you have, or would present a flawed argument. Everything seems to check out and I don't see you as a threat, so I rescind my vote, but I don't know who else to vote for at this point, and I don't think ever doing a no lynch is productive, so I'll wait to make another decision.

unvote: Shane

[Job Reborn]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

I explained the reasoning a page back but I'm gonna go with Job. He did accuse IBC for something that is very normal. Kind of a reach. I'll probably change my vote, but this seems suspicious.
Unvote: No Lynch
Vote: Job

I've been explaining my reasoning all along : no lynching is the only option that has a 100% chance of helping mafia, he started the no lynching wagon, etc, etc. Have yet to feel the need to change my vote (i.e. no one has stricken me enough as a scum, ibc hasn't made much to change my mind and hasn't been threaten by a number of votes against him), though ATL has risen a bit on my suspicion meter.

[zachsaints52]

Anyone know how many of us is Mafia to determine the exact percentages?

Or is that not known/against the rules to know?

[fenikz]

It's unknown sometimes there is more than 1 evil entity, like in the werewolf game there was a zombie

[zachsaints52]

Originally Posted by fenikz

It's unknown sometimes there is more than 1 evil entity, like in the werewolf game there was a zombie

Thanks for the update. Still kinda new to this game.

Vote: No-Lynch

[CJSchneider]

Originally Posted by fenikz

It's unknown sometimes there is more than 1 evil entity, like in the werewolf game there was a zombie

Why do you have to bring up old ****?

[TheBoyWonder22]

Yeah, but it's normal to do that. Most of us would have even if IBC hadn't. I didn't even notice who said it. I agree ATL is a little suspicious, but until we truly find suspect I like my logic. I'll change mine when someone else deems themselves suspicious. I've changed it three times now so I'm gonna sit and wait.

[ImBrotherCain]

Last game Caddy ran it was 1/4 mafia.. We also had 13 less people.

I defended myself as to why I voted no lynch... I also maintain that unless someone can provide a decent enough argument that makes me question someone I will stick with my no lynch vote.

[fenikz]

Just realized how many votes it's gonna take to lynch someone

[diabsoule]

Originally Posted by fenikz

Just realized how many votes it's gonna take to lynch someone

Yeah, it's going to take a metric **** ton.

[Caddy]

Actually, 17.

[D-Unit]

I just got the PM that the game was started. I don't really have time to catch up right now, but I will tomorrow at work.

[Jvig43]

Unless someone comes forth with any evidence they got from their powers the decision should be no lynch. If no one can come up with anything other than just random speculation we might as well not do the mafia's job for them by making the mistake of killing one of our own. Further more, if we do end up randomly getting a mafia goon, it would be without any relation to anyone else and wouldn't be super beneficial with the odds most likely stacked against us shooting in the dark. If someone comes forward with information from one of their abilities, we'll know the next day whether they were teling the truth or not. Really this isn't as hard as everyone makes it out to be whenever something like this starts.

VOTE: No Lynch

[scottyboy]

I've made up my decision that it's not worth risking 2 innocent lives with random killings based off of no evidence. For now...

vote: no LYNCH

[vidae]

I'll vote no lynch as well, but we better get some evidence tomorrow or we're just doing the Mafias job for them.

vote : no lynch

edit: typos, on stupid phone

[Raiderz4Life]

Originally Posted by D-Unit

I just got the PM that the game was started. I don't really have time to catch up right now, but I will tomorrow at work.

I'm in this boat. Spent the whole day turning wrenches.

But I really do need to catch up on everything. So tomorrow at work i'll get to it.

[Wootylicous]

What the hell guys ?!

DEEP is bad i know it. bad bad bad.

[JoeJoeBrown]

Someone is nervous talking.

VOTE SHANE

[ccB]

I see no convincing arguments


Vote: NO LYNCH

[Mr. Goosemahn]

Seeing as how there is no evidence,

vote: No Lynch