Psych Mafia Game Thread - Town Wins!

[Job Reborn]

Caddy could be Yin, or anyone working in pharmaceuticals. We're already pretty much living a second Day 1 (i.e: We're in the dark, going off nothing) thanks to not having any info from the prior day. Quick-lynching someone who can't even say anything will hardly help us find other bad guys in the upcoming days.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Alright well I don't see a better option right now tbh. I don't think Grizz would include the drugs unless it was relevant and based on past games I have a hard time believing Caddy is an investigator with the way he came out like that day one, at least not a town aligned investigator.

vote: Lynch Caddy

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by Job Reborn

Caddy could be Yin, or anyone working in pharmaceuticals. We're already pretty much living a second Day 1 (i.e: We're in the dark, going off nothing) thanks to not having any info from the prior day. Quick-lynching someone who can't even say anything will hardly help us find other bad guys in the upcoming days.

Ok. Well i think there's a good chance Caddy is Yin, then Forenci stole the drugs and silenced him.

Don't know who Gus is, but would be be an investigator in a mafia game?

[vidae]

I very much doubt Gus is an investigator. That doesn't add up in my mind.

And I still don't think Caddy is evil, so unless we have more information to go off of, I will not be voting for him.

[BeerBaron]

Pro-tip: The next time someone calls you out as being suspicious, pretend to be silenced. No one will vote you off!

[Rob S]

I really think Caddy is evil fwiw.

vote: Caddy

[SuperPacker]

Well Caddy claims to be an investigator, but no one associated with drugs could be an investigator and one of the main people associated to drugs, is evil.

Vote: Caddy

[Grizzlegom]

Updated Vote Count:

Caddy (5): BeerBaron, IBC, Todd, Rob, SP
Broth (1): Renji

With 22 people alive, 12 are needed for majority.

[Bulldogs]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

Pro-tip: The next time someone calls you out as being suspicious, pretend to be silenced. No one will vote you off!

It worked for your fellow mafia member Wooty!

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

Pro-tip: The next time someone calls you out as being suspicious, pretend to be silenced. No one will vote you off!

It backfires when you're about to get lynched and you can't come in to defend yourself.

[BeerBaron]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

It backfires when you're about to get lynched and you can't come in to defend yourself.

Well aware. I wouldn't have brought it up if I wasn't willing to take that risk.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

Well Caddy claims to be an investigator, but no one associated with drugs could be an investigator and one of the main people associated to drugs, is evil.

Vote: Caddy

Two things:

1) No one associated with drugs could be an Investigator? We don't know that.

2) Just because Forenci was a Thief doesn't mean the drugs were from Caddy.

I think you guys are going to kill an innocent person.

[BeerBaron]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

Well aware. I wouldn't have brought it up if I wasn't willing to take that risk.

Lynching caddy I mean. It would seem that the silencer is out of commission anyway.

[BeerBaron]

Originally Posted by vidae

Two things:

1) No one associated with drugs could be an Investigator? We don't know that.

2) Just because Forenci was a Thief doesn't mean the drugs were from Caddy.

I think you guys are going to kill an innocent person.

Mine was not special, I took it pretty much from here:

************.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Thief

The Thief is an informative role that targets one player each night to steal an item related to that player's role. They are told what they stole.

In essence, Thief is a flavorful Flavor Cop, and on occasion a permanent Roleblocker.

I just made my temporary roleblocker instead of permanent.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by vidae

Two things:

1) No one associated with drugs could be an Investigator? We don't know that.

2) Just because Forenci was a Thief doesn't mean the drugs were from Caddy.

I think you guys are going to kill an innocent person.

Are any of the people you named as possible investigators associated with Drugs?

Well Forenci appears to have silenced Caddy and he was found with drugs in his hand. I don't know for sure obviously, but it looks like Forenci targeted Caddy, silenced him and stole his drugs, and then died.

[BeerBaron]

Also, again, Forenci is "in jail," not dead. A distinction wouldn't have been made if there was not a reason for it. (Back to the whole "less is more" rule of modding.)

I think that will play a part headed forward.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by vidae

Two things:

1) No one associated with drugs could be an Investigator? We don't know that.

2) Just because Forenci was a Thief doesn't mean the drugs were from Caddy.

I think you guys are going to kill an innocent person.

1) We don't actually know he's an investigator.

2) They weren't from Forenci's character and Grizz wouldn't have included them unless it was relevant, leading me to believe it's a clue about Caddy.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

Also, again, Forenci is "in jail," not dead. A distinction wouldn't have been made if there was not a reason for it. (Back to the whole "less is more" rule of modding.)

I think that will play a part headed forward.

ncst8 was also "arrested." Shane was killed though so I'm not sure what this all means.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

Also, again, Forenci is "in jail," not dead. A distinction wouldn't have been made if there was not a reason for it. (Back to the whole "less is more" rule of modding.)

I think that will play a part headed forward.

Forenci was 'knocked unconsious'. Maybe he could back alive?

[Job Reborn]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

Forenci was 'knocked unconsious'. Maybe he could back alive?

Pierre Despereaux is pretty much a jailbreak artist. I'm betting we'll see him again.

[BeerBaron]

Originally Posted by Job Reborn

Pierre Despereaux is pretty much a jailbreak artist. I'm betting we'll see him again.

Yeah, I don't know much about the show, but that is the kind of thing I was expecting to hear.

There wouldn't be a distinction made if there wasn't a reason for it.

[Raiderz4Life]

I'm not trusting Caddy and I think BB and other ppl have brought very good points.

lynch caddy

[Dr. Gonzo]

Vote: Caddy

Wasn't able to post day one but Caddy coming out as a cop screamed ******** to me.

[Grizzlegom]

Updated Vote Count:

Caddy (7): BeerBaron, IBC, Todd, Rob, SP, Gonzo, R4L
Broth (1): Renji

With 22 people alive, 12 are needed for majority.

[Job Reborn]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

I think you find out more with voting patterns/ who defends a person than you do discussion. As a town we most likely know nothing. So we find out information when we vote for people and how people react to the voting.

No one will stick up for someone unless they are known part of a team. Which 8 times out of 10 means they are Mafia. We have seen how 1st days can spiral out of control when people get hung up on little things. I mean do I really have to reference the 25 page Shane vs Gonzo crap. So you can advocate "discussion" I will preach action.

- Says voting patterns are critical
- Says people won't stick up for eachother unless they are part of a team, which is utterly false.
- Discourages discussion.
- Encourages a quick lynch.

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Dude... Its day one. What better reason is their to lynch a person besides that.

- Again pressing for the quick lynch.

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

One out of how many in all the games we have played. The town are sheep. They follow in lynch trains and they follow investigators. Its rare to see someone stick their neck on the line for someone they don't know is good. Right now we need to get people to think for themselves, go with their gut and analyze posts/ voting patterns.

That will give the town more than most investigations I feel.

- Complains about people being sheeps despite having encouraged people to sheep in his previous posts.
- Suddenly says we should analyze posts after having discouraged discussion in prior posts.

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

I would say a bit of both but if Grizz mod kills him then we most likely have another vote making it more likely we kill another townie and go down 2 good guys day one to another **** up by ncst8

- Argues AGAINST having an additionnal day lynch. This makes no sense, as the most often the town has a say on who gets killed, the better the town's chances of finding mafia. Here we have IBC basically taking a stand AGAINST having more information, and AGAINST getting more votes for his beloved voting patterns, effectively contradicting himself in a BIG way.

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

With all that said it looks as if Caddy may be silenced. Does this mean that JBond protected Caddy and Forenci targeted him as well?

Something to think about.

- First to bring up Jbond possibly protecting Caddy. Did you have any information has to who the mafia really targeted?

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

I was thinking this as well... but you are kinda acting like a crazy person right now which is slightly off putting.

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

I was thinking that myself. Does that mean it was Caddy's or was it just Forenci's character?

- Twice : Someone brings up a good point, and goes "Oh I was also thinking that". Care to actually bring it up the next time? Seems to me like you're either faking to be analyzing the posts like the other guys have been, or that you are withholding information.

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Honestly at the moment we don't have a better option. Everyone is going to clamor for information but most investigators hold back for a couple days.

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

If someone can provide evidence the other way I might be persuaded but right now I think this is the best course of action.

- Once again discouraging discussion.
- Once again going for a very fast lynch.

Another big point of interest : While repeating a couple of times that observing voting patterns was KEY to the town's success, he's been favoring a rapid lynch of someone in which EVERY voting person actually votes for the same person. Voting patterns really aren't carrying that much information when they consist of a single, fast, unargued train.

So there. I think IBC's play has been more than suspicious.

vote: IBC