Psych Mafia Game Thread - Town Wins!

[Bulldogs]

I suppose we wait to see if info comes out. If not we vote for who has been the most suspicious and see who backs who.

[ImBrotherCain]

Well we all skipped something.

JBond was a triggered Bodyguard. With is claim of "Worst role ever" in the discussion thread it could be safe to make the assumption that he was forced to protect someone last night and was killed because of it.

[Bulldogs]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Well we all skipped something.

JBond was a triggered Bodyguard. With is claim of "Worst role ever" in the discussion thread it could be safe to make the assumption that he was forced to protect someone last night and was killed because of it.

I saw that, I just assumed he protected Caddy.

edit: that doesn't make sense, Forenci couldn't kill. Maybe a thief was the trigger. I have no idea.

[vidae]

I for one believe Caddy. As far as JBond goes, I have no idea. Anyone have any information?

[SuperMcGee]

Of course Ken is gone after one day as a bodyguard

[ImBrotherCain]

Does Ken specifically guard anyone in the show? That could give us a hint to who may have been attacked last night (assuming it wasn't JBond).

[ATLDirtyBirds]

The move by Caddy is very much out of character. Caddy's usually very big on the long discussions, wait and see, and second guessing.

For him to come out and say, "I'm a cop, protect me" (when he usually calls out people for demanding protection, knows the potential of him being the lazy/incompetent cop, etc) warrants heavy suspicion. I believe he not only called for protection, but called for an investigation into himself by the watcher? Odd.

[vidae]

Ken isn't a.. protector in the show. He's an intern for the agency who doesn't get paid and who Shawn and Gus basically take advantage of, haha. I think maybe he could have protected Shawn or Gus, but it said he was a backup protector, right? Maybe he hasn't protected anyone yet.

[vidae]

Oh it says TRIGGERED Bodyguard.. that is different. Maybe Shawn or Gus were attacked because I don't recall him having any contact with anyone else..

[ATLDirtyBirds]

Also, unless someone comes forward with some info, I wouldn't mind going for a lynch on Snicho. Since we learned nothing day one, it's worth noting that there has been a definite link between Snicho and Caddy.

[SuperMcGee]

Originally Posted by ATLDirtyBirds

The move by Caddy is very much out of character. Caddy's usually very big on the long discussions, wait and see, and second guessing.

For him to come out and say, "I'm a cop, protect me" (when he usually calls out people for demanding protection, knows the potential of him being the lazy/incompetent cop, etc) warrants heavy suspicion. I believe he not only called for protection, but called for an investigation into himself by the watcher? Odd.

Dirty Cop could be a possibility? That's occurred a few times on the show, sometimes as a pretty big plot advancer.

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by vidae

Oh it says TRIGGERED Bodyguard.. that is different. Maybe Shawn or Gus were attacked because I don't recall him having any contact with anyone else..

Yeah I was going to say he isn't a backup. Thats why I asked if he protected anyone in the show because of the Trigger.

There is the distinct possibility that he was attacked last night.

[Rob S]

How many cops is normal for a game of this size?

[Bulldogs]

I'd say 3 max, maybe 2.

[vidae]

Well we can list what we know.. we know Jules, Lassiter, and Henry are in the show, and maybe even the Chief. Maybe even McNabb. That's 5. I doubt all of them would have investigative powers though. Mary is probably around somewhere too, but I don't know what he'd do as far as powers go.

I'm thinking we have a protector or two and two or three (at most) investigators.

[SuperPacker]

Just read up what i missed and i'm thinking BB is an investigator and investigated Caddy last night, so he saw Caddy was evil and is now trying REALLY HARD to lynch him.

OR

BB has an evil (non important) role and is trying to lynch one of the most important characters. Then if we lynch Caddy (who is good) he could come out and say he is an investigator and that his results must have been tampered with.

[vidae]

It is rather weird how much BB wants Caddy to die. And it isn't a little bit, it's a lot. It just struck me as odd.

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by vidae

It is rather weird how much BB wants Caddy to die. And it isn't a little bit, it's a lot. It just struck me as odd.

Not if you read the few pages of BB going insane in the Frieza game.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by vidae

It is rather weird how much BB wants Caddy to die. And it isn't a little bit, it's a lot. It just struck me as odd.

That's what is making me think BB is an investigator, he investigated Caddy and the results back back as evil.

I dont see why else he would be this determined.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Not if you read the few pages of BB going insane in the Frieza game.

BB was evil in that game...Hmmm...

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

BB was evil in that game...Hmmm...

I mean more of his reasoning behind it less about alliance. Caddy used his power as "Goku" to basically herd the sheep that was the town. His first argument was that Caddy was attempting to do the same.

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

Alright so, I'm going to throw this out there.

I'm calling ******** on Caddy. ******** ******** triple ******* ****-sucking ********.

1.) Given the amount of participants in each game, the likelihood of him being a Cop back to back like that is about 1/744.

2.) He saw how easily he could lead the sheep-like townies to slaughter if he wanted to in the last game. The town is inherently stupid and will rally behind anyone they can feel like they trust.

3.) Claiming Cop on day 1 like that as a baddie serves two purposes:
A.) Potentially steals protection from legitimate powered townies.
B.) An actual cop counter-claiming basically outs that person as a cop, giving the mafia their target.

It was a stupid move and I like the odds of him being evil and trying to send the town for a loop far better than him being an actual cop.

Caddy commanding the town and leading them right off a cliff is happening (maybe literally in the game) over my dead body.

Vote: Caddy

Here is his reasoning

[BeerBaron]

I went insane in that game to try and lead the town as far away from Fenikz/Frieza as possible since I was already suspicious and had used up my powers.

Here, I legitimately think that caddy is BSing and him outing himself as a cop day one is an attempt to lead the town astray for the reasons I mention here and here and here.

[vidae]

I dunno, I guess I fall into the category of people who believe Caddy is good. I don't find what he did to be at all suspicious. A little dumb sure, but not suspicious.

[Gay Ork Wang]

have we thought about lynching superpacker yet