Gladiator Game Thread - Game Killed

[Brothgar]

They couldn't kill him in the arena so they killed him in his tent! COWARDS! I wish to name my opponent!

[Brothgar]

If ATL wants to see my skills in battle let him see it first hand!

Vote ATL

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by broth223

They couldn't kill him in the arena so they killed him in his tent! COWARDS! I wish to name my opponent!

No. You fight someone we think is bad, not who you want to fight.

[SuperPacker]

I don't mind fighting!

[ImBrotherCain]

Updated Vote Count:

SP (2): Rob, ATL
Cigaro (1): JR
CJ (1): killswitch
ATL (1): Broth

With 24 alive, 13 are needed for majority.

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

I don't mind fighting!

Why do you want to fight? Are you evil and therefore should be sent to the arena?

[Shane P. Hallam]

Ask and you shall receive to me. I'm surprised SP wants to fight, but if he wants to, I won't object right now.

Vote: SuperPacker

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by Caddy

No. You fight someone we think is bad, not who you want to fight.

And SP is evil because???

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by Shane P. Hallam

Ask and you shall receive to me. I'm surprised SP wants to fight, but if he wants to, I won't object right now.

Vote: SuperPacker

This is the type of brazen decision which will end in our deaths in the arena. Wouldn't you rather be a free man, than a dead one?

[FlyingElvis]

Originally Posted by Snicho

We at least now that it isnt the Mercenery side doing the killings... So in that case shouldnt we try and take out the evil guys before we take out the neutral guys?

That's dangerous logic. I think Firefly was the only game I've played that had only one evil group. Every game since has been 2 evil groups and one or two serial killers. Assuming the Hunnics are neutral is as faulty as assuming they give a **** about our freedom.

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by FlyingElvis

That's dangerous logic. I think Firefly was the only game I've played that had only one evil group. Every game since has been 2 evil groups and one or two serial killers. Assuming the Hunnics are neutral is as faulty as assuming they give a **** about our freedom.

It isn't unfounded logic. Remember CMD died at night, which most likely means he was killed by the 'evil' faction.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by FlyingElvis

That's dangerous logic. I think Firefly was the only game I've played that had only one evil group. Every game since has been 2 evil groups and one or two serial killers. Assuming the Hunnics are neutral is as faulty as assuming they give a **** about our freedom.

They already said they don't give a **** about freedom. They only want freedom for the strongest few. They want the weak among us cast out or thrown into the Lion's Den. If that isn't a symbol of evil, I don't know what is.

[FlyingElvis]

Originally Posted by Caddy

It isn't unfounded logic. Remember CMD died at night, which most likely means he was killed by the 'evil' faction.

Yes, but the faulty part is to assume that means CMD (Hunnics) are good because of it. I'm all for using any group we can to win our freedom (see: Woot outing Gonzo LOL!) but still think we need to be careful about our assumptions. SK's are neutral, ya dig?

[Brothgar]

Isn't blue standard color for good?

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by FlyingElvis

Yes, but the faulty part is to assume that means CMD (Hunnics) are good because of it. I'm all for using any group we can to win our freedom (see: Woot outing Gonzo LOL!) but still think we need to be careful about our assumptions. SK's are neutral, ya dig?

Oh I 100% agree we should be wary, but it is much more likely he died at the hands of the evil faction, than an SK.

[BeerBaron]

Updated Vote Count:

SP (3): Rob, ATL, Shane
Cigaro (1): JR
CJ (1): killswitch
ATL (1): Broth

With 24 alive, 13 are needed for majority.

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by broth223

Isn't blue standard color for good?

Are you saying you are blue too?

[FlyingElvis]

Originally Posted by Caddy

Oh I 100% agree we should be wary, but it is much more likely he died at the hands of the evil faction, than an SK.

Well, my thought is that, instead of SK we have a group of neutrals. Mercenaries working together for the glory would make sense as neutral.

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by Caddy

Are you saying you are blue too?

I say nothing just an observation. Every mafia game ever blue = good red = bad purple = neutral.

[RufusMcDaniel]

We want to have competitors who are willing to fight, right?

Well, if SuperPacker wants to go, why not let him. And yeah...for ATL too.

Vote: SuperPacker

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by FlyingElvis

Well, my thought is that, instead of SK we have a group of neutrals. Mercenaries working together for the glory would make sense as neutral.

That makes a lot of sense. They sound like the trained warriors and are surely a threat to the enslaved members of town. If we can try and figure out some evil people we could have ATL nominate them and then force them to fight a trained warrior.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by broth223

I say nothing just an observation. Every mafia game ever blue = good red = bad purple = neutral.

And Silver?

[ImBrotherCain]

Updated Vote Count:

SP (4): Rob, ATL, Shane, Rufus
Cigaro (1): JR
CJ (1): killswitch
ATL (1): Broth

With 24 alive, 13 are needed for majority.

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by broth223

I say nothing just an observation. Every mafia game ever blue = good red = bad purple = neutral.

That is false. Numerous different colours have been used. Relying on them is stupid. Tell us what use you are to the town, otherwise I'd be happy for you to fight a trained warrior.

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by Caddy

That is false. Numerous different colours have been used. Relying on them is stupid. Tell us what use you are to the town, otherwise I'd be happy for you to fight a trained warrior.

Please asking for a role reveal this early in the game makes YOU more suspicious than I am.