Historical Figures "USA vs Britain" - America Wins!

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by Cigaro

Er what? I could have just been ignorant of the setup, but I have never known this to be the case.

Also, I refuse to believe that Roosevelt has already been taken out. So I am just going to pretend he is actually William McKinley.

Like I said in the mafia discussion thread yesterday, I'm going out of town soon, and may not be back until tomorrow afternoon. I will try and check in on my phone but no guarantees.

In every game I have ran a Mafia member can kill and use their ability. For example:
Lets say Caddy is a Roleblocker. Caddy can Roleblock BeerBaron and be sent by the Godfather to kill Shane.

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

...did you investigate him or just randomly receive the message?

Randomly received message.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by Cigaro

Er what? I could have just been ignorant of the setup, but I have never known this to be the case.

Also, I refuse to believe that Roosevelt has already been taken out. So I am just going to pretend he is actually William McKinley.

Like I said in the mafia discussion thread yesterday, I'm going out of town soon, and may not be back until tomorrow afternoon. I will try and check in on my phone but no guarantees.

[ooc] Hey now! William McKinley is my 5th cousin and an all-around badass. How dare you speak ill of him! [/ooc]

[Grizzlegom]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

In every game I have ran a Mafia member can kill and use their ability. For example:
Lets say Caddy is a Roleblocker. Caddy can Roleblock BeerBaron and be sent by the Godfather to kill Shane.

This. The factional kill is separate from the individual role and both actions can be done in the same night. That's how I've also always seen it and how I've always operated.

[Grizzlegom]

Originally Posted by broth223

Randomly received message.

Perhaps a neighbor?

[Cigaro]

Wouldn't a neighbor be known from the start?

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

This. The factional kill is separate from the individual role and both actions can be done in the same night. That's how I've also always seen it and how I've always operated.

Another example is that Shane as the Godfather in the DDN game sent TH to do the killing seeing as his role was the least important in their eyes.

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by Cigaro

Wouldn't a neighbor be known from the start?

Wha? Are you drunk this morning?

A neighbor chooses one person a day to send a predetermined message through the mod.

[Bulldogs]

Not a terrible night for us, but McGee would have been extremely useful down the line. The only person who really stands out to me today is SP, but that could be just because he's playing dumb at the moment.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Wha? Are you drunk this morning?

A neighbor chooses one person a day to send a predetermined message through the mod.

I'm not familiar with the neighbor role. Does the neighbor choose what is said and can thus spew whatever **** they want to or does the moderator choose the message and thus can be taken as fact?

[Cigaro]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Wha? Are you drunk this morning?

A neighbor chooses one person a day to send a predetermined message through the mod.

That is not even close to what the MafiaWiki describes the role as being.

[Grizzlegom]

Hmm, the only time I've seen neighbor on here, it was the variety Cain described but yea, definitely seems like a disconnect here.

[Brothgar]

I was thinking friendly townie as well. But I wouldn't be surprised at all if this was a mafia ploy. On top of that Rufus SP and SBH seem to be very protective of each other. Just something to keep an eye out for.

[Cigaro]

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

Hmm, the only time I've seen neighbor on here, it was the variety Cain described but yea, definitely seems like a disconnect here.

I don't know what game the role was used in, but that must be some DC only version of the role. It is normally a role that acts like a mason, except for the fact that the person never knows the alignment of their neighbor. There is no talking to a different person each night or knowing if they are harmless or not.

[Brodeur]

You people, making me catch up.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Vote: SP

Stands out the most to me and I think his lynch tells us a fair amount. Also nice to see evil Vidae make an appearance. Every game evil Vidae shows up I can't help but think he could not be tipping that he is evil that easily but he keeps proving me wrong. That said I am more confident that SP is evil for now.

[BeerBaron]

Vote count:

D-Unit (1) - Todd
ATL (1) - SP
SuperPacker (1) - Gonzo

With 23 alive, 12 are needed for majority.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

Vote: SP

Stands out the most to me and I think his lynch tells us a fair amount. Also nice to see evil Vidae make an appearance. Every game evil Vidae shows up I can't help but think he could not be tipping that he is evil that easily but he keeps proving me wrong. That said I am more confident that SP is evil for now.

I really have no idea what I've done to look evil to anyone.

[jrdrylie]

I don't think anything Vidae has done has been indicative of evil Vidae. Yes, he talked right after I called him out but he was literally typing at the same time I was. And his next post was pretty calm as well. He didn't start bitching and moaning like he usually does when evil.

[Brodeur]

Originally Posted by CashmoneyDrew

Re-reading day 1, the only thing that really sticks out to me is Brodeur switching to being in favor of "no lynch" all of a sudden and then qualifying it with an excuse. That doesn't necessarily mean he's evil, though.

That's it unfortunately.

It's not an excuse exactly, it's a change of strategy based on success in the last couple of games I've been involved in.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by vidae

I really have no idea what I've done to look evil to anyone.

You have just been a little angry is all. Usually people who are good like having a little suspicion thrown their way. When you are evil you tend to get really ******* pissed off and really ******* defensive. Again though, I think sooner or later you will check evil Vidae so that no longer becomes an indicator.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

You have just been a little angry is all. Usually people who are good like having a little suspicion thrown their way. When you are evil you tend to get really ******* pissed off and really ******* defensive. Again though, I think sooner or later you will check evil Vidae so that no longer becomes an indicator.

This game? I don't think I've been angry at all this game. I barely posted yesterday (and I didn't miss much anyway, it being day one and all) and I've only questioned ATL but that appears to have been cleared up, enough for my liking anyway.

I don't think SP has been acting evil either.. maybe not playing this the best way possible early in the game, but I just don't get an evil vibe.

[Cigaro]

OK well I have to leave now :(

It is hard for me to say I have any suspicions worth acting upon, I thought day one moved too quickly(I do think the later voters in that area may need be looked at) to gather a lot of suspicions and it is very early day two. If I had to name someone, it would be SP, he has seemed a little off, but I am not going to be voting for him for the time being simply because it is only a relative hunch.

I will try and check in on my phone later this afternoon, although I will certainly be a little lost as I doubt I will be rereading everything I miss all on my phone. Will be back and active as usual come tomorrow.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by vidae

This game? I don't think I've been angry at all this game. I barely posted yesterday (and I didn't miss much anyway, it being day one and all) and I've only questioned ATL but that appears to have been cleared up, enough for my liking anyway.

I don't think SP has been acting evil either.. maybe not playing this the best way possible early in the game, but I just don't get an evil vibe.

Ok. So you defending SP may be nothing and you may have a point but it is interesting. Who is the most suspicious person to you right now? If you had to lynch somebody who would it be?

[vidae]

Have a good trip Cigaro.