SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by vidae

I don't know. Technically he's still an Investigator. It just seems weird that Shane would give us four people who had or could potentially have investigative powers is all.

I'm not going to answer for game design as I am not the designer I can only say what I am. Also you are right there is nothing saying that TBW 100% is who he says he is nor you for that matter.

[TheBoyWonder22]

Originally Posted by vidae

The headphones mean nothing. Neither did the alarm clock. You hit on two, and those weren't surprises to anyone.

You're scrambling now.

The alarm clock indicates that he can be awakened by the mafia. Does YFS hold an alarm clock in his hand in the picture where he's next to that guy in the bed? Someone post it.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Brothgar

I'm not going to answer for game design as I am not the designer I can only say what I am. Also you are right there is nothing saying that TBW 100% is who he says he is nor you for that matter.

You're right, which is why I said in a previous post that right now everyone should be a suspect. I'm not above that either. I'm not lying about who I am though, and I haven't lied once this game.

I do believe TBW has, and continues to lie about his role and stuff he has found. That's why he has my vote.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

The alarm clock indicates that he can be awakened by the mafia. Does YFS hold an alarm clock in his hand in the picture where he's next to that guy in the bed? Someone post it.

First of all, awakened by the Mafia? That is a suuuuuuper stretch. Second, that wasn't YFS if we're thinking of the same pic. That was someone else. I can't remember who off the top of my head, but the guy in the bed was Mojo Drew.

[Brothgar]

he is thinking of keak

[OSUGiants17]

Jesus we have a lot of investigators. Broth, I believe that you are the backup, but TBW could be GF and just appear good, then again I find it hard to believe that the GF would claim something as suspicious as thief. Now I am conflicted. If we don't vote TBW, I am willing to vote for SP or vikes. Also, TBW can you reveal your character if you haven't already done so?

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Brothgar

he is thinking of keak

Ya, him. The alarm clock still makes no sense. The headphones still make no sense. None of his story makes sense.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

Jesus we have a lot of investigators. Broth, I believe that you are the backup, but TBW could be GF and just appear good, then again I find it hard to believe that the GF would claim something as suspicious as thief. Now I am conflicted. If we don't vote TBW, I am willing to vote for SP or vikes. Also, TBW can you reveal your character if you haven't already done so?

I think this is where he messed up. Someone earlier (I can't remember who) tried to say that we've never had a mafia aligned Thief, but we have. I remember because I was in that mafia with the Thief (I can't remember what game it was, but I remember having a Thief very clearly).

I still think TBW is the GF. I think all of this has been made up from day one, and I'm not sure anything will change my mind at this point.

[Brothgar]

I think we should go through all of our investigators/trackers/etc both known and unknown see if anything comes up. There is no need to rush this.

[TheBoyWonder22]

It's a metaphor damnit. I'll reveal JR then since I have a feeling this is the last day. He's our doctor. I found a pill bottle of his two nights ago.

[TheBoyWonder22]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

Jesus we have a lot of investigators. Broth, I believe that you are the backup, but TBW could be GF and just appear good, then again I find it hard to believe that the GF would claim something as suspicious as thief. Now I am conflicted. If we don't vote TBW, I am willing to vote for SP or vikes. Also, TBW can you reveal your character if you haven't already done so?

I'm Yoda the Thief.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

It's a metaphor damnit. I'll reveal JR then since I have a feeling this is the last day. He's our doctor. I found a pill bottle of his two nights ago.

A few posts ago you said you thought we had two mafia and a SK left. How is this the last day? You just outed our Doctor for absolutely zero reason...

You're the GF, aren't you? Some GFs are Rolecops. Maybe that's how you're making all of this up.

Yeah, you're evil. I'm 100% sure now.

[OSUGiants17]

Why would you reveal the doctor without his permission? Total dick move.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

Why would you reveal the doctor without his permission? Total dick move.

It makes absolutely ZERO sense considering he just said he thought there were three evils left. No idea why he is playing like this at all.

[TheBoyWonder22]

I mean if I get killed today this is the last day. The SK gets a kill as does the mafia and trivia winner. That's potentially 4 guys lost today and tonight. If we play this right we can take out one guy of the mafia or the SK. JR was asking me his role, but now this has gotten too serious and you all need to know I'm what I say I am and not be brainwashed by this attack on my credibility.

[TheBoyWonder22]

And if I'm bs'ing then I guess that he's not really the doctor right?

[vidae]

You're the Mafia GF and rolecop. You were able to find out roles and think up items to "steal" from them.

When this game is over I'd like to know why you picked some of the more ridiculous items you did and tell us how they connect to us.

[Brothgar]

CMD - Likely good as said by Todd known investigator
Broth - 100% good as said by Broth who is good.
JR - Good or GF as shown by Woot's follow investigation
SP- Claim Shane P Hallam
Vidae - Claim Scott Wright

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

Good:
Todd
Jrd(possible GF perhaps?)
Woot
Snicho
OSU
CMD

Likely good but not entirely confirmed:
R4L
vidae
SP
scotty(alarm clock kind of confirmed him as fenikz, possible GF?)
vikes-boe(tracked but didn't do anything, could be the GF but then we're assuming the GF doesn't have an investigative ability which might be possible with a mafia this size)

Unknowns:
Deep-claims Grizz
Rob
broth(something about a stache, either hines fisch)
rufus-claims scotty
forenci
Jensen(comes up good in R4L's investigation, claims townie)

Vikes - Tracked by Woot did nothing.
Deep - Claim Grizz
Snicho - considered good by Todd

[vidae]

Deep has said that he was Diabs, not Grizz.

[OSUGiants17]

Those against lynching TBW can you at least help us out and say why and who you would rather go after? I don't want to rush, but I don't want the days to drag out unnecessarily either

[TheBoyWonder22]

Haha whatever vid, I've got work until 9:30. I hope you guys make the right choice.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

Haha whatever vid, I've got work until 9:30. I hope you guys make the right choice.

The right choice is killing the guy who has basically made no sense the entire game and lied multiple times. I'm confident we'll make the right choice and lynch you soon.

[jrdrylie]

Well, since it is late in the game, I was going to say that TBW could reveal my role, because maybe it clears him. He definitely could be a role cop, either Godfather or otherwise. I'm still sticking with my Vikes vote though.

[Brothgar]

If he was a role cop and knew you were the doctor why not kill you strait off?

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Brothgar

If he was a role cop and knew you were the doctor why not kill you strait off?

It sounds like he found it out last night.