SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by vidae

I thought you got one watch and one track? Didn't you use your watch last night?

Uhhhhhhh, no. I was the guy that tracked Brodeur to Rob S.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

Uhhhhhhh, no. I was the guy that tracked Brodeur to Rob S.

My bad. Could have sworn you said you watched Rob S and Brodeur targeted him.

[ImBrotherCain]

Alright guys I just wanted to let you know that my participation is going be at an all time low. Just drove 5 hours and now at the hospital.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by vidae

My bad. Could have sworn you said you watched Rob S and Brodeur targeted him.

I figured much lower chance of hitting on a watch night one than a track.

[BeerBaron]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Alright guys I just wanted to let you know that my participation is going be at an all time low. Just drove 5 hours and now at the hospital.

What happened?

[CJSchneider]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Alright guys I just wanted to let you know that my participation is going be at an all time low. Just drove 5 hours and now at the hospital.

Take care of family first.

[OSUGiants17]

Well last night I was leaning Brody, but now I'm convinced we should lynch TH. He is either lying with his whole "I have to kill every night" to cover up or he is just going to have to take a shot in the dark most nights and could take out one of us.

Vote: Lynch TH

[Dr. Gonzo]

OSU did it really take someone making that argument to change your mind? This is what I don't get, the info on TH has been out for a while and all it took was one person being firm about it to start the lynch train. Again, I could get on board, he was number two option for me and I am starting to think we will learn a ton about from his death.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Alright guys I just wanted to let you know that my participation is going be at an all time low. Just drove 5 hours and now at the hospital.

Are you okay? What's going on?

[SuperMcGee]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

OSU did it really take someone making that argument to change your mind? This is what I don't get, the info on TH has been out for a while and all it took was one person being firm about it to start the lynch train. Again, I could get on board, he was number two option for me and I am starting to think we will learn a ton about from his death.

Much like those that vote early and those who vote late, those who vote in the middle of the pack are very suspicious. Should TH end up being good (if he is lynched), then I'm thinking OSU is one who stands out. I know that this has not been moving at breakneck speed today, so I might have to cut a little slack to those jumping on with the crowd (see: what I will probably do), but it does seem a little odd that he is now "convinced"

[BeerBaron]

Originally Posted by SuperMcGee

Much like those that vote early and those who vote late, those who vote in the middle of the pack are very suspicious. Should TH end up being good (if he is lynched), then I'm thinking OSU is one who stands out. I know that this has not been moving at breakneck speed today, so I might have to cut a little slack to those jumping on with the crowd (see: what I will probably do), but it does seem a little odd that he is now "convinced"

Vote early - suspicious
Vote middle - suspicious
Vote late - suspicious
Don't vote - suspicious
Bringing up that it's suspicious no matter when you vote - suspicious

On a serious note, the point about people ass-dragging when Brody was the vote but are now suddenly on board with the TH vote do deserve some suspicion. I know some of us were waiting for trivia, but it's worth keeping in mind nonetheless.

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 30 members remaining, 16 votes are needed for a majority:

TitanHope (10) - Brothgar, vidae, jrdrylie, BeerBaron, Forenci, CJSChneider, Woot, TBW, Todd Bertuzzi, OSUGiants

Brodeur (5) – GOW, Bulldogs, Dr. Gonzo, Caddy, Rob S

OSUGiants (3) - Cashmoneydrew, ATLDirtyBirds, scotty

Bulldogs (2) - Jensen, Brodeur

[OSUGiants17]

I just don't get how I can never play a game without seeming suspicious. Literally the only game people believed me was the game that I was the innocent child and had BB(who was running the game) confirm it for me, but until he did, they didn't believe me.

[vidae]

Everyone is suspicious every game. And they should be, at least at the start. This is not new, for you or anyone.

[RufusMcDaniel]

Don't like how Rob is telling us that he has a night action and protection, because in my opinion there is nothing that backs his claim. Yeah, Brodeur targeted him, but how do we know he isn't just a townie or hell even a mafia member that Brodeur hit on, if he is indeed a jailkeeper.

Anyway, so there's been a huge turn on the votes and now TH is the majority. I don't disagree with it. Obviously having someone out there who can kill and is known is dangerous. Especially, as a vigilante who is required to kill each night.

I guess I would lean towards voting that way as well. Reducing the deaths each night is vital (obviously). Looking at our options, which seem to be Brodeur and TH. Would you rather hit on a SK or a roleblocker as a best case scenario? Yeah, it would suck losing the vigilante, but without any information, those kills at night are random shots in the dark.

Now, the last thing I was thinking. What if TH is the SK and there is no vigilante. If that were the case, could there be two mafias? I only suggest it because the game is larger than our recent games, and from being in the Wire game that was similar in size, we saw two mafias battle it out. At the same time, there was two SKs, so who knows. Part of me was thinking the Mecca gang as one group and just trolls as another. Maybe I'm over thinking it here.

But with that said, with what others have said and thinking it through. Right now TH seems like the best option. Hate to do, but sorry.

Vote: TitanHope

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 30 members remaining, 16 votes are needed for a majority:

TitanHope (11) - Brothgar, vidae, jrdrylie, BeerBaron, Forenci, CJSChneider, Woot, TBW, Todd Bertuzzi, OSUGiants, Rufus

Brodeur (5) – GOW, Bulldogs, Dr. Gonzo, Caddy, Rob S

OSUGiants (3) - Cashmoneydrew, ATLDirtyBirds, scotty

Bulldogs (2) - Jensen, Brodeur

[Gay Ork Wang]

You people do realise, that if he wasnt the vigilante, the real one would probably speak up to give us an easy kill?

[vidae]

It isn't so much his role, but how his role reads. He has to kill every night or a random townie dies. He has no idea who is good or bad, and with the numbers how they are, he has a greater chance of killing a townie than a Mafia member.

He HAS to attack someone, and that is dangerous for us.

[Wootylicous]

******* hell.

Unvote TH
Vote brodeur

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 30 members remaining, 16 votes are needed for a majority:

TitanHope (10) - Brothgar, vidae, jrdrylie, BeerBaron, Forenci, CJSchneider, TBW, Todd Bertuzzi, OSUGiants, Rufus

Brodeur (6) – GOW, Bulldogs, Dr. Gonzo, Caddy, Rob S, Woot

OSUGiants (3) - Cashmoneydrew, ATLDirtyBirds, scotty

Bulldogs (2) - Jensen, Brodeur

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

You people do realise, that if he wasnt the vigilante, the real one would probably speak up to give us an easy kill?

If there is a vigilante...

[Gay Ork Wang]

i mean if he goes for guys that are really suspicious anyways, that gives us the chance to not waste lynches. He has chances to kill the mafia. It would also give us someone that is good, which is really important to have. Someone that is proven to be good is a huge asset.

[Gay Ork Wang]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

If there is a vigilante...

Four kills, no vigilante?

[Wootylicous]

I'm very suspicious of you jr.

[Gay Ork Wang]

The thing is, i agree he can be dangerous to the town. But we can still kill him if we have no concrete ideas tomorrow. Killing him now with Brodeur having a high chance of being evil just doesnt make sense to me.