SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[vidae]

wtf boe doesn't have a buttchin.

And I'm not all that suspicious of TBW anymore. I really was, but the last few days have cooled that for me.

I am still very suspicious of CMD. I'd be shocked if he wasn't the SK.

vote : CMD

Going with my gut here.

[vikes_28]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

Uh yeah do you have anything concrete on how I'm suspicious? And how can I and the two guys I've put pressure on all be suspicious? That makes no sense.

That's true. I have little doubt that CMD is anyone but the serial killer. He's really the only one who hasn't let us know who is. Suspicious? I think so.
Vote CMD

[TheBoyWonder22]

I can get behind CMD. The only other two I could see as the SK are vidae and SP.

unvote: brothgar
Vote: CMD

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by vikes_28

That's true. I have little doubt that CMD is anyone but the serial killer. He's really the only one who hasn't let us know who is. Suspicious? I think so.
Vote CMD

I haven't let anyone know who I am. I just don't know that the serial killer would have an additional power like the cheat.

[SuperPacker]

Have we ever seen a serial killer than can gift? That wouldn't make any sense. I don't see why we would lynch CMD.

[vidae]

We've never seen a "cheat" either. Who knows what he can do. Like I said, I'm going with my gut. I don't have any proof at all, I just don't like what has been going on with him.

[TheBoyWonder22]

Well he still hasn't explained the gift incident even though I've asked 3 times.

[jrdrylie]

Yeah, it would be nice to know exactly how the cheat worked. There is no reason not to fully explain it (unless he is lying). If he doesn't, I could be swayed to vote for him.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by vidae

We've never seen a "cheat" either. Who knows what he can do. Like I said, I'm going with my gut. I don't have any proof at all, I just don't like what has been going on with him.

The cheat makes sense with the trivia aspect of the game. But then makes no sense as a serial killer on top of that.

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 10 players remained, 6 are needed for a majority

CashMoneyDrew (2) - vikes, TBW

Vikes (2) - jrdrylie, SuperPacker

[vidae]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

The cheat makes sense with the trivia aspect of the game. But then makes no sense as a serial killer on top of that.

How does it not make sense? We've never seen a cheat before. You have no idea how Shane decided to implement it.

I'm not saying it's a slam dunk or anything, but if you have something better to go on I'd be happy to hear it.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by vidae

How does it not make sense? We've never seen a cheat before. You have no idea how Shane decided to implement it.

I'm not saying it's a slam dunk or anything, but if you have something better to go on I'd be happy to hear it.

Deep, Broth, vikes, you, TBW.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

Deep, Broth, vikes, you, TBW.

That isn't something to go on, that is a list of five names. Give me your thoughts on each of those you listed and I'd be happy to read them.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by vidae

That isn't something to go on, that is a list of five names. Give me your thoughts on each of those you listed and I'd be happy to read them.

Deep - By default of not thinking CMD is the SK. Doesnt post much and hasnt revealed his role.

Vikes - Votes for good people to be lynched, doesnt vote for bad people to lynch. Hasn't posted much.

Broth - Hasnt posted as much as usual. Goes for '3 hours' when I ask people to role reveal and gives him enough time to have an excuse as to why he let it go to the trivia.

TBW - Claims to be a thief, but the items he finds are inconsistent and you'd assume after stealing from scotty that he'd have an item that hinted that he was evil.

[SuperPacker]

Are we reallly going to lynch someone who has a role that suggests he isn't the serial killer, when there are other suspicious people that don't have a role that suggests that.

[vidae]

unvote : CMD

I'll give a few people time to weigh in but then we really need to decide on someone. We're pretty close to winning.. only the GF and SK left and we win, so lets try to play this like we have brains.

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 10 players remained, 6 are needed for a majority

CashMoneyDrew (2) - vikes, TBW

Vikes (2) - jrdrylie, SuperPacker

[SuperPacker]

People know that he trivia is soon, right? It would be nice if another good person didn't have to die.

[jrdrylie]

Yeah, getting to trivia is not ideal, especially since one good person (me) wont be able to participate.

[CashmoneyDrew]

I feel extremely confident that at least one of the 3 voting for me is anti-town. I'm gonna go with TBW here. Been after me for multiple days and is withholding info.
lynch: tbw

[vidae]

Well it looks like we're about to hit trivia again. Hopefully whoever wins picks a good target. Ugh.

[Shane P. Hallam]

Today is General Sport's Trivia Time!

Same rules apply, first to get them all right wins it! If no one does, most correct wins (earliest entry=tiebreaker)





1. Who was the first athlete to be paid more than the President?

2. In Australian rules football, what do the men in raincoats do?

3. What 1960s American Olympic team was beat by a high school team in a scrimmage?

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 10 players remained, 6 are needed for a majority

CashMoneyDrew (2) - vikes, TBW

Vikes (2) - jrdrylie, SuperPacker

TheBoyWonder (2) - CMD, vidae

[vidae]

I've been thinking about it a lot and I think TBW is full of crap. The items that have made sense have come out after he knew their roles, and the other ones still don't make any bit of sense. I honestly think he has been making this up since day one.

vote : TBW

[vikes_28]

I'm going to stick with CMD at this point. I get that TBW's findings don't make sense, but at least he has revealed his role and TRIED helping us find who potential mafia is.